The Great Brink’s Robbery: Boston’s ‘Crime of the Century’, 1950

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the evening of Tuesday 17 January 1950, the Brink’s armoured-car depot at 165 Prince Street, in Boston’s North End, was closing for the day. Five employees were still inside, counting the day’s takings. Then seven men walked in through five locked doors — as if they owned the keys, because in effect they did — wearing pea coats, chauffeur’s caps and rubber Halloween masks. In under half an hour they had bound the employees, emptied the vault, and vanished into the winter night with $2,775,395.12. It was, at the time, the largest robbery in the history of the United States. The newspapers called it the “crime of the century” and the “perfect crime.” It took almost six years to solve — and it was solved by the robbers themselves.

Eighteen months of planning

The Brink’s job was not a spur-of-the-moment crime. Its origins lay roughly two years earlier, when Anthony “Fats” Pino, a career criminal known in Boston’s underworld as a “case man” — someone who studied targets — began to consider the Brink’s depot. The company had moved to its Prince Street building from a previous location on Federal Street, and Pino and his associates watched it closely.

The planning was meticulous. For about eighteen months, the gang studied the depot’s routines: when the vault was opened, when the most money was inside, and how the employees moved through the building. They made wax impressions of keys so they could have copies cut. They memorised alarm patterns. According to later accounts, they even rented a warehouse and rehearsed the robbery using a mock-up of the vault room, timing every step.

The crew numbered eleven in all. Joseph “Big Joe” McGinnis was, according to one gang member’s later account, the originator of the plan; Pino recruited the others, including Stanley “Gus” Gusciora, Joseph “Specs” O’Keefe, Henry Baker, Adolph “Jazz” Maffie, Michael Geagan, James Faherty, Thomas “Sandy” Richardson, Vincent Costa and Joseph Banfield. Seven would go inside; the rest would drive the getaway cars, keep watch, and handle the money afterwards. They agreed that not a cent of the loot would be spent until the statute of limitations had run out.

The night of 17 January

At about 7:10 p.m., the seven men entered the building. Their copied keys opened door after door. The employees were caught completely by surprise. The robbers bound them and set to work on the vault, taking $1,218,211.29 in cash and $1,557,183.83 in checks, money orders and other securities. No one was hurt, and no alarm was raised. The whole job took about twenty minutes.

Outside, the getaway was equally smooth. Within the hour, the men had scattered, and the money — nearly all of it — had disappeared with them. When the employees freed themselves and raised the alarm, the police found almost nothing: no fingerprints of value, no witnesses who could describe a face behind a rubber mask, and no useful clues. The FBI joined the investigation, but for years the case went nowhere. Boston’s underworld kept its silence, and the gang kept its promise not to spend the money.

Six years of silence

The statute of limitations on the robbery in Massachusetts was six years. As 1950 gave way to 1951, then to 1955, the deadline crept closer. The investigators’ hopes faded. Then the gang began to fall apart.

Joseph “Specs” O’Keefe, who had been entrusted with part of the loot, believed his share had been withheld or shortchanged by his own crew. Already serving time on unrelated charges after he and Gusciora were arrested in Pennsylvania for attempted burglary, O’Keefe decided he had nothing left to protect. In January 1956, he began talking to investigators, laying out the planning, the players and the mechanics of the robbery in detail.

His confession arrived with almost impossible timing. On 12 January 1956 — just five days before the statute of limitations was due to expire — the FBI arrested six of the gang: Baker, Costa, Geagan, Maffie, McGinnis and Pino. Indictments followed for all eleven men connected with the case.

The trial and the missing millions

Eight defendants went to trial in 1956 and were convicted; seven received life sentences for armed robbery, while McGinnis was convicted as an accessory before the fact along with other offences. O’Keefe pleaded guilty and testified for the prosecution, receiving a four-year sentence; he was released in 1960. Gusciora died before the trial, and one other member of the gang had also died before he could be convicted.

The money, though, was almost entirely gone. Of the $2.775 million stolen, less than $60,000 was ever recovered. In June 1956, investigators found more than $57,700 hidden in a cooler behind an office partition on Tremont Street in Boston; $51,906 of it could be identified as Brink’s money. The rest — more than $1.15 million in cash alone, plus the checks and securities — was never accounted for. Some of it was almost certainly spent quietly in the years after the statute of limitations expired; some may have been lost, hidden, or simply never found. O’Keefe later cooperated with the writer Bob Considine on The Men Who Robbed Brink’s, published in 1961, but even his account did not explain where the money went.

The robbery entered popular culture. At least four films were based on it in whole or in part, most famously The Brink’s Job (1978), directed by William Friedkin and starring Peter Falk as Tony Pino. The building at Prince Street is long gone, replaced by redevelopment, but the case remains the benchmark against which American heists are measured.

What the record shows

What is documented is this: on 17 January 1950, seven men entered the Brink’s building at 165 Prince Street, Boston, bound five employees and stole $2,775,395.12 — $1,218,211.29 in cash and $1,557,183.83 in checks, money orders and other securities — then the largest robbery in American history; the crime remained unsolved for almost six years; in January 1956, gang member Joseph O’Keefe, in prison on unrelated charges, described the robbery to investigators; six men were arrested on 12 January 1956, five days before the six-year statute of limitations expired; eight men were convicted at trial in 1956 and given life sentences, while O’Keefe pleaded guilty and testified for the prosecution; and less than $60,000 of the money was ever recovered.

One point is genuinely disputed: who led the gang. O’Keefe’s account named Joseph McGinnis as the mastermind, while another member, Michael Geagan, said Anthony Pino was the leader. The sources disagree, and neither version should be presented as settled fact. The exact division of the money, and where the unrecovered millions went, is also unknown — and after seventy-five years, it is likely to stay that way.

Sources

Leave a Comment