The Manson Family Trial, 1970–1971: Seven Lives, One Courtroom

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

On the morning of 9 August 1969, a housekeeper arriving at a rented home on Cielo Drive in Los Angeles found the bodies of actress Sharon Tate, 26 — eight and a half months pregnant — and three guests: celebrity hairstylist Jay Sebring, 35, coffee heiress Abigail Folger, 25, and her boyfriend Wojciech Frykowski, 32. Outside, in a car in the driveway, was 18-year-old Steven Parent, a friend of the groundskeeper. The following night, supermarket executive Leno LaBianca, 44, and his wife Rosemary, 38, were killed in their home in Los Feliz.

Seven people had been killed in two nights. The trial that followed, lasting nine and a half months, was one of the longest and most expensive in California history — and one of the strangest, as the defendants turned the courtroom into a stage. This article focuses on the trial and the evidence presented there; the details of the killings are kept brief, out of respect for the victims and their families.

The Victims

Sharon Tate was a film actress married to director Roman Polanski, who was in London. Jay Sebring was a well-known hairstylist; Abigail Folger, daughter of the Folger coffee family, was a social worker; Wojciech Frykowski was a Polish writer and friend of Polanski’s. Steven Parent had come that night to visit the groundskeeper and was leaving when he encountered the attackers.

Leno ran a chain of grocery stores; Rosemary managed a dress shop. They had no connection to Tate or her circle, and their deaths made clear the killings were not a vendetta against one household — the victims had been chosen, in effect, at random.

The “Family” and the Investigation

The killings were linked to a commune of young people at the Spahn Ranch, a former film set outside Los Angeles, led by Charles Manson, a 34-year-old ex-convict. Manson exercised intense control over his followers — the press called them the “Family” — through long lectures, drugs and isolation.

For months the investigation stalled. The break came from inside the group: Susan Atkins, arrested on other charges, described the killings to fellow inmates, and a grand jury indicted Manson, Atkins, Patricia Krenwinkel, Leslie Van Houten, Charles “Tex” Watson and Linda Kasabian on 8 December 1969. Watson fought extradition from Texas for nine months, so the others were tried without him. Kasabian was granted immunity on 10 August 1970 in exchange for testifying.

The Trial Opens

The trial opened in Los Angeles in the summer of 1970 before Judge Charles H. Older, with Vincent Bugliosi leading the prosecution. It ran until March 1971, cost roughly $1 million, and was followed daily in the press and on television.

The prosecution faced an unusual problem: Manson had not been present at the Tate house, and had entered the LaBianca home only briefly before leaving. To convict him, Bugliosi had to prove Manson had ordered the killings and controlled those who carried them out. His case rested on Linda Kasabian, present at both houses as a lookout, and on a motive theory the prosecution called “Helter Skelter.”

According to Bugliosi, Manson told his followers the Beatles’ song “Helter Skelter” prophesied an apocalyptic race war, and that the killings were meant to be blamed on Black militants to trigger it. Words including “Helter Skelter” had been left at the LaBianca home. This was the prosecution’s theory; Manson denied responsibility and offered no alternative explanation. Historians have debated ever since how far “Helter Skelter” explains what happened, and how far it was a framework the prosecution built to make a baffling crime intelligible.

Kasabian’s testimony was the heart of the case: over days on the stand she described both nights in detail, and Bugliosi later said that without her, convicting Manson would have been extremely difficult.

A Courtroom in Turmoil

The trial was repeatedly disrupted. Manson carved an X into his forehead, and the three women copied him, later shaving their heads. They sang and chanted in court, and at one point Manson lunged at the judge and had to be restrained. The three women insisted Manson had nothing to do with the killings, while Manson at times tried to take over his own defence.

In November 1970, the defence rested without presenting evidence. Manson then asked to testify; in a rambling statement on 20 November he spoke of society’s failures, saying, “The children that come at you with knives are your children.” On cross-examination, Bugliosi asked him whether he thought he was Jesus Christ.

The same month, Van Houten’s lawyer, Ronald Hughes, failed to appear in court on 30 November and was never seen again. His disappearance has been speculated about ever since, but no one was ever charged in connection with it.

Verdict and Sentence

After eleven days, the jury found all four guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy on 25 January 1971 — Manson, Atkins and Krenwinkel on seven counts each, Van Houten on the two LaBianca counts. On 29 March 1971, the jury fixed the penalty as death for all four; Judge Older formally imposed the sentences on 19 April.

Watson was tried separately and convicted in October 1971 on seven counts of first-degree murder; he too was sentenced to death. Manson was convicted separately, in December 1971, of two further murders — musician Gary Hinman and stuntman Donald “Shorty” Shea.

None of the death sentences was carried out: on 18 February 1972, the California Supreme Court ruled in People v. Anderson that the state’s death penalty was unconstitutional, and every death sentence in California was reduced to life imprisonment with the possibility of parole.

The Aftermath

The legal story did not end in 1971. Van Houten’s conviction was overturned on appeal because the court had failed to declare a mistrial after her lawyer’s disappearance; her second trial hung, and at a third trial in 1978 she was again convicted and sentenced to seven years to life. After 53 years in prison, she was released on parole in July 2023.

Susan Atkins died in prison on 24 September 2009; Charles Manson died of natural causes on 19 November 2017, aged 83, still in custody. Patricia Krenwinkel and Charles Watson remain in prison.

The trial left a lasting mark on American law. It showed that a person who directs a killing can be convicted of murder even without being present, and it became a defining example of a trial overwhelmed by its own publicity. For the families of the seven victims, however, the verdicts were the point: those responsible had been held to account in a court of law.

What the record shows

  • On 8–10 August 1969, seven people were killed in Los Angeles: Tate, Sebring, Folger, Frykowski and Parent at Cielo Drive, and the LaBiancas in Los Feliz.
  • The trial ran from June 1970 to March 1971 before Judge Charles H. Older in Los Angeles. Vincent Bugliosi prosecuted; Linda Kasabian, granted immunity, was the key witness.
  • The prosecution’s motive theory — “Helter Skelter,” an apocalyptic race war supposedly prophesied in a Beatles song — remains debated; Manson denied responsibility and offered no alternative motive.
  • On 25 January 1971, all four were convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy; on 29 March they were sentenced to death. Charles “Tex” Watson was convicted separately in October 1971.
  • In February 1972, People v. Anderson abolished California’s death penalty, and all the sentences were commuted to life imprisonment.
  • Van Houten was convicted again in 1978 and released on parole in July 2023 after 53 years. Atkins died in prison in 2009; Manson died in custody in 2017. Krenwinkel and Watson remain in prison.

Sources

Leave a Comment