The Murder of Sherri Rasmussen: The Bite Mark That Waited Twenty-Three Years

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

On the morning of Monday 24 February 1986, John Ruetten left the condominium on Balboa Boulevard in Van Nuys, Los Angeles, that he shared with his wife of three months, and went to work. When he came home that evening, Sherri Rasmussen was dead. She had been beaten and shot three times in the chest. The apartment looked as if it had been ransacked. The Los Angeles Police Department called it a botched burglary, and moved on.

The case stayed cold for twenty-three years. It was solved in the end by a single piece of evidence that had been collected on the first day and then lost inside the system for nearly two decades: a swab taken from a bite mark on Sherri Rasmussen’s left forearm. When that swab was finally tested, it produced a DNA profile that belonged to a woman — and that woman turned out to be a Los Angeles police detective, and the former girlfriend of Sherri’s husband. Her name was Stephanie Lazarus. She had worn a badge for the whole twenty-three years the case was unsolved.

A nurse, an engineer, and an ex-girlfriend

Sherri Rasmussen was 29, a director of nursing at Glendale Adventist Medical Center in Los Angeles. She had married John Ruetten, an engineer, in November 1985. They had bought the condominium in Van Nuys together and were three months into their marriage when she was killed.

Ruetten had previously been in an on-again, off-again relationship with Stephanie Lazarus, a Los Angeles police officer. The relationship had ended shortly before he married Sherri. Lazarus, by several accounts, had not taken the break-up well. She had confronted Sherri at least once, and Sherri’s father, Nels Rasmussen, later said that his daughter had told him about a woman who had been harassing her.

None of that was pursued at the time. The original investigation treated the killing as a burglary that had gone wrong. A vase had been broken over Sherri’s head, drawers had been pulled open, and electronic equipment was missing. The detectives did not look closely at the people in Sherri’s life, and they did not follow up on her father’s suspicion that Lazarus was involved. The case went into the files, and stayed there.

A swab in a freezer

The one piece of evidence that mattered was collected on the day of the murder. A criminalist had swabbed a bite mark on Sherri’s left forearm for saliva. In 1986, DNA technology was in its infancy, and the swab could not be used. It was put into storage, and then it was lost.

In 2004, an LAPD criminalist named Jennifer Francis pulled the Rasmussen file during a review of old cases. The envelope holding the bite-mark swab was missing from the department’s evidence. She tracked down the original criminalist and eventually found the swab in a freezer at the Los Angeles County Coroner’s Office, where it had sat for eighteen years. In 2005, the saliva produced a DNA profile — and the profile belonged to a woman. That single fact changed everything: the attacker was not a male burglar, as the original investigation had assumed.

But the case still did not move. It was not until 2008 that cold case detectives Jim Nuttall and Pete Barba took another look. They built a list of five women who might have left the bite mark, and eliminated them one by one until only Lazarus remained.

The coffee cup

In May 2009, investigators followed Lazarus to a Costco store in Simi Valley and retrieved a cup and straw she had thrown away. The DNA from the cup matched the DNA from the bite mark on Sherri Rasmussen’s arm. The odds of the bite-mark DNA belonging to someone other than Lazarus were later put at 1.7 sextillion to one.

On 5 June 2009, detectives Greg Stearns and Dan Jaramillo asked Lazarus to come downstairs at Parker Center, the LAPD’s headquarters, supposedly to consult on an art theft. She checked her gun, as jail rules required. Then they told her the interview was about Sherri Rasmussen. When they mentioned DNA, she said, “If you guys are claiming I’m a suspect, then you know I got a problem with that,” and asked to leave. She was arrested the same day and charged with first-degree murder.

The arrest made headlines around the world: a serving LAPD detective, charged with a murder committed twenty-three years earlier, on the strength of DNA she had left on her victim’s arm.

The trial

The trial opened in early 2012 before Judge Robert Perry. The prosecution’s case, as the deputy district attorney Shannon Presby summed it up, was “a bite, a bullet, a gun barrel and a broken heart.” The bite was the DNA. The bullet was the murder weapon: a .38 calibre gun, the same calibre as the weapon that had killed Sherri, and a .38 revolver that Lazarus had reported stolen in March 1986, weeks after the murder. The gun barrel was never recovered — Lazarus has since told the parole board she threw it into bushes near a freeway. The broken heart was the motive: jealousy over a man who had left her for another woman.

Lazarus maintained her innocence throughout. But on 8 March 2012, after a five-week trial, the jury took less than a day to find her guilty of first-degree murder. On 11 May 2012, Judge Perry sentenced her to 27 years to life in prison. The conviction was upheld by the California Court of Appeal in 2015, and the California Supreme Court declined to review it.

In November 2023, Lazarus finally admitted to killing Rasmussen, telling a parole board that she had gone to the condominium that day but had not planned to kill her. She did not apologise to the victim’s family. A parole panel recommended her for release that month, but a state panel later blocked it, and in October 2024 a panel found good cause and rescinded the grant. Her next parole hearing is not expected until 2028. As of 2026, she remains at the California Institution for Women in Corona.

How the case was solved

The Rasmussen case was solved, in the end, by two things: a piece of evidence that refused to disappear, and a technology that did not exist when the crime was committed. The bite-mark swab was taken in 1986, lost for eighteen years, found in a coroner’s freezer in 2004, and turned into a DNA profile in 2005. It took another four years, and a second look by cold case detectives, before that profile was matched to a suspect.

The case also stands as a record of how an investigation can fail. The original detectives assumed a burglary and stopped looking. The victim’s father named the right suspect in 1986 and was ignored. The killer was a police officer, working in the same department that was supposed to catch her, and for twenty-three years no one in that department connected her to the crime. The district attorney at the time of the arrest, Steve Cooley, said it plainly: “Had it not been for DNA the case might not have been solved.”

For Sherri Rasmussen’s family, the conviction brought an answer, but not a simple one. The woman who killed their daughter had been a police officer for more than two decades, and had been promoted to detective while the case sat in a file. The family had waited twenty-three years to learn what had happened, and the answer was that the system had failed them twice: once in 1986, when the investigation stopped, and again for the two decades that followed, while the evidence sat in a freezer and no one thought to test it.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Sherri Rasmussen, 29, director of nursing at Glendale Adventist Medical Center, was murdered on 24 February 1986 in the Van Nuys condominium she shared with her husband, John Ruetten, whom she had married three months earlier. She had been beaten and shot three times in the chest. A criminalist swabbed a bite mark on her left forearm on the day of the murder. The LAPD treated the case as a botched burglary, and it remained unsolved for more than twenty years. The swab was lost, found in 2004 in a freezer at the Los Angeles County Coroner’s Office, and produced a female DNA profile in 2005. Cold case detectives reopened the case in 2008–2009. In May 2009, DNA from a discarded coffee cup matched the bite-mark DNA to Stephanie Lazarus, an LAPD detective and Ruetten’s former girlfriend. Lazarus was arrested on 5 June 2009. On 8 March 2012 a jury found her guilty of first-degree murder, and on 11 May 2012 she was sentenced to 27 years to life. The conviction was upheld on appeal in 2015. In November 2023 Lazarus admitted the killing to a parole board; a parole grant was later rescinded in October 2024, and she remains in prison.

Unverified or unproven: The precise sequence of events inside the condominium on 24 February 1986 rests on the prosecution’s reconstruction, not on a witness. Lazarus has said she did not plan to kill Rasmussen when she went to the condominium that day; that claim has not been tested in court. The murder weapon, a .38 revolver Lazarus reported stolen in March 1986, has never been recovered, so the link between her gun and the killing is circumstantial. Whether other officers knew or suspected Lazarus’s involvement before 2009 has never been established.

Sources

Leave a Comment