The Kidnapping of Jaycee Dugard, 1991: Eighteen Years, and a Chance Encounter

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

The Kidnapping of Jaycee Dugard, 1991: Eighteen Years, and a Chance Encounter

On the morning of 10 June 1991, 11-year-old Jaycee Lee Dugard left her home in Meyers, California, near South Lake Tahoe, to walk to her school bus stop. She was wearing a pink outfit and carrying a backpack. Her stepfather, Carl Probyn, had dropped her off at the bus stop, a short distance from the house. He watched as a grey car approached. Two people — Phillip Garrido and his wife, Nancy Garrido — forced Dugard into the car and drove away. Probyn heard her scream. She was gone.

Dugard would not be seen again for more than 18 years. She was held, for all of that time, in a concealed area behind the Garridos’ house at 1554 Walnut Avenue in Antioch, California, less than 200 miles from where she had been taken — in tents, sheds and lean-tos, separated from the world by fences and makeshift structures. Her captor was already a convicted kidnapper and rapist, on parole supervision.

The search that found nothing

Searches began immediately after Dugard’s disappearance, and several people had witnessed the kidnapping. But no reliable leads were generated. The case went cold, and it stayed cold for 18 years, while Dugard’s family did not know whether she was alive.

During her captivity, Dugard gave birth to two daughters, fathered by Phillip Garrido. She was 14 when the first was born, and 17 when the second was born. She was known to the Garridos by the name Allissa, and she later testified that she had not said her own name in 18 years. This article records those facts as the court record does, without graphic detail.

Phillip Garrido had a criminal record that should have made him visible to the system. He had abducted and raped several women, and had been sentenced to 50 years in prison for rape and abduction in Reno, Nevada. He served 11 years of that sentence and was released on parole. At the time of Dugard’s kidnapping, he was on parole for a 1976 rape.

The failures in supervision

Garrido’s parole supervision became, after Dugard’s rescue, the subject of a formal review. California’s inspector general later found numerous lapses. Parole officers had visited the Garrido home roughly 60 times over the years without uncovering Dugard’s presence, despite some visits in which the concealed area should, in the inspector general’s judgement, have been noticed. A retired parole officer, Edward Santos Jr., visited the home several times and said he saw nothing out of the ordinary.

In 1999, supervision of Garrido’s parole was taken over by the state of California from the federal government. The failures continued. Dugard later sued the state of California on account of the lapses by law enforcement that contributed to her continued captivity. In 2010, the state awarded the Dugard family $20 million in settlement. A separate lawsuit against the federal government was dismissed.

The chance encounter

The case broke open, not through the parole system, but through a chance encounter at a university. On 24 August 2009, Phillip Garrido visited the campus of the University of California, Berkeley, accompanied by two adolescent girls — later discovered to be his and Dugard’s daughters — to ask about holding a religious event on campus. Campus police officers Lisa Campbell and Ally Jacobs found his behaviour unusual and ran a background check. It showed that Garrido was a registered sex offender on parole for kidnapping and rape.

Berkeley alerted Garrido’s parole officer, Edward Santos Jr. Santos ordered Garrido to bring the two girls to the parole office in Concord, California, on 26 August. Garrido arrived with his wife, the two girls, and a woman introduced as Allissa. During questioning, the woman was pressed on her real name. She later testified that she told the officer she could not say it, because she had not said her name in 18 years — and then she wrote it down. She was Jaycee Dugard, now 29 years old.

Garrido and his wife, Nancy, were arrested that day. Dugard was reunited with her mother, Terry Probyn, the same day.

The guilty pleas

The Garridos initially pleaded not guilty to charges that included kidnapping, sexual assault and false imprisonment. On 28 April 2011, they changed their pleas to guilty — to kidnapping and rape. On 2 June 2011, Phillip Garrido was sentenced to 431 years to life in prison. Nancy Garrido was sentenced to 36 years to life.

Dugard testified at the proceedings. She described, in her own words, a child who had wanted only to go home, and who had told her captor that her family did not have a lot of money, if he was holding her for ransom. Her testimony, and her memoir A Stolen Life, published in 2011, are the record of what she endured — and of how she reclaimed her name after 18 years without being allowed to use it.

Aftermath

Since her return, Dugard has reclaimed her story through her memoir and through public advocacy. In 2010 she founded the JAYC Foundation — “Just Ask Yourself to Care” — to support families and survivors of trauma and abduction.

The case remains a study in two things at once: the resilience of a child who survived 18 years of captivity and came home, and the failure of a supervision system that visited her captor’s home some 60 times and never found her.

What the record shows

Jaycee Dugard, 11, was taken on 10 June 1991 while walking to a school bus stop in Meyers, California. She was held for 18 years in a concealed area behind a house in Antioch, California, by Phillip and Nancy Garrido. She was identified on 26 August 2009, after Garrido’s visit to the University of California, Berkeley, led his parole officer to summon him to a meeting. The Garridos pleaded guilty on 28 April 2011. Phillip Garrido was sentenced on 2 June 2011 to 431 years to life; Nancy Garrido was sentenced to 36 years to life. The state of California settled a lawsuit by the Dugard family for $20 million in 2010.

Dugard was 11 when she was taken and 29 when she came home. She has since told her own story, in her own name.

Sources

Leave a Comment