Jonathan Wild: The Thief-Taker Who Ruled London’s Underworld

Reading Time: 8 minutes ·

On the morning of 24 May 1725, a cart carried Jonathan Wild through the streets of London to the gallows at Tyburn. For a decade he had been the city’s most famous crime-fighter, the self-styled “Thief-Taker General of Great Britain and Ireland,” consulted by the government and praised in the newspapers for recovering stolen property and sending thieves to the gallows. The crowd that lined his route did not cheer him. They pelted him with stones and filth, and the noise drowned out the prison chaplain’s prayers for the condemned. Wild had built his power by standing on both sides of the law at once, and on that morning both sides finally caught up with him.

His story matters because it exposed how the system of his age worked. London in the early 1700s had no police force: when a citizen was robbed, the state offered a £40 reward for catching a felon and left the catching to anyone willing to try. Wild saw that this arrangement could be run as a business, and for ten years he ran it better than anyone else.

A buckle-maker’s apprentice from Wolverhampton

Jonathan Wild was born in Wolverhampton in 1682 or 1683, the first of five children in a poor family; his exact birth date is not known. His father was a carpenter, his mother sold herbs and fruit in the local market, and he was apprenticed to a local buckle-maker after attending the Free School in St John’s Lane. He married and had a son, but left them behind when he moved to London in 1708.

London, a city of around 600,000, had seen property crime rise sharply since about 1680, and there was no citywide police force — only local constables and watchmen with little power and less appetite for chasing thieves. Wild’s education in crime began in prison. In March 1710 he was arrested for debt and sent to the Wood Street Compter, one of the City’s debtors’ prisons. There he met Mary Milliner, a prostitute who, according to Daniel Defoe, brought him into her circle of thieves. Released in 1712 under an Act of Parliament for the relief of insolvent debtors, he went to live with Milliner in Covent Garden and began working as a fence — a receiver of stolen goods.

Learning the trade from Charles Hitchen

Wild’s teacher, and later his rival, was Charles Hitchen. In 1711 Hitchen had paid £700 for the post of City Under Marshal, effectively London’s top policeman. He abused the office on an extravagant scale, taking bribes to release thieves and extorting money from brothels and pickpockets, and was suspended in 1713. Around 1713, Hitchen hired Wild as one of his assistants in thief-taking — profitable work, since the government paid a £40 reward for catching a felon. Wild learned the trade: how to use the reward system and make thieves pay for protection.

When Hitchen was restored to office in 1714, Wild went his own way. He opened a small office in the Blue Boar tavern, run by Mrs Seagoe in Little Old Bailey, and later moved it to the Old Bailey itself. He still called himself Hitchen’s “Deputy,” though he had no official standing, and carried a sword as a mark of supposed authority. The break turned into open war. Hitchen tried to expose Wild in an 1718 pamphlet, and Wild replied by accusing Hitchen of visiting “molly houses,” the homosexual brothels of the day. The scandal finished Hitchen as a threat, and Wild was now alone at the top.

The double system

Wild’s method depended entirely on a gap in the law: at the time, no statute punished a person who merely received stolen goods. Wild ran a gang of thieves who stole by pickpocketing and robbery, and he kept the stolen goods himself. He then waited for the victim to advertise the loss in the newspapers, as victims routinely did. At that point, Wild would claim that his “thief-taking agents” had found the merchandise, and he would return it to its rightful owner for a reward — a fee usually less than the cost of replacing the goods, so victims paid it gladly.

The arrangement gave him power over everyone involved: the thieves who worked for him had to hand over their takings and accept his cut, or Wild could simply hand them to the authorities as thieves. The thieves he did hand over were rivals, or members of his own gang who had crossed him. By his own testimony, more than sixty thieves were sent to the gallows through his evidence, and he collected the £40 reward each time.

Wild’s public face was heroic. In 1718 he began calling himself “Thief-Taker General of Great Britain and Ireland,” and his office in the Old Bailey was a busy place: victims of crime would come to him, sometimes before they had even announced their losses, and discover that his agents had already “found” their missing items. In 1720 the Privy Council consulted him on controlling crime; unsurprisingly, he recommended raising the rewards for evidence against thieves, and within the year the reward for capturing a thief went from £40 to £140. In reality, it was gang warfare dressed up as a national service.

The rival who would not stay caught

Wild’s downfall began with a thief he could not control: Jack Sheppard, a young housebreaker and former carpenter’s apprentice from Spitalfields, who had worked with Wild in the past and then struck out on his own. Small, quick, and polite in the public’s eyes, Sheppard became a working-class hero, and his repeated escapes made Wild look foolish.

In April 1724, one of Wild’s men arrested Sheppard for a burglary in Clare Market. He was put in St Giles’s Roundhouse and escaped within three hours. Arrested again in May, he escaped from the New Prison at Clerkenwell with his companion Elizabeth Lyon, known as Edgworth Bess. Betrayed by Lyon after Wild’s informant William Field found his hiding place, Sheppard was arrested a third time on 23 July and put in Newgate Prison. Tried on 13 August on three charges of burglary, he was acquitted of two but convicted of the burglary of his former master William Kneebone’s house on 12 July, on the evidence of Wild, Field, and Kneebone. Sentenced to death, he escaped again on 31 August, the night the death warrant arrived, and was caught a fourth time on 9 September on Finchley Common and returned to Newgate in shackles.

Meanwhile, on 9 October, Wild’s men arrested Joseph “Blueskin” Blake, a highwayman and Sheppard’s partner. On 15 October, Blueskin was tried for the same burglary of 12 July and convicted on Wild’s evidence. After the trial, Blueskin begged Wild in the courtroom to have his sentence commuted to transportation. Wild refused. Enraged, Blueskin slashed Wild’s throat with a pocketknife, and Wild collapsed and was carried to a surgeon. Taking advantage of the disturbance, Sheppard escaped yet again on 16 October, breaking through chains, padlocks, and six iron-barred doors. He was found for a fifth and final time on 1 November, and this time he was placed in the centre of Newgate, where he could be watched at all times, loaded with three hundred pounds of iron weights.

On 11 November, Blueskin was hanged; five days later, Sheppard was hanged at Tyburn. Wild, confined to his bed while the wound in his throat healed, attended neither execution. The man who had put Sheppard there was now despised.

Arrest, trial, and the gallows

As Wild recovered, his control over his gang slipped. He used violence to carry out a jailbreak for one of his men, then went into hiding for several weeks. On 15 February 1725, Wild and Quilt Arnold were arrested for the jailbreak, and Wild was placed in Newgate. With public feeling against him, his own men began to turn on him, giving evidence about his whole operation — the gang, the rewards, and the bribery of public officers. His trial took place at the Old Bailey on 15 May 1725.

Wild was tried on two indictments of privately stealing fifty yards of lace from Catherine Statham, a lace-seller who had visited him in prison on 10 March. He was acquitted of the theft charge. But on the second charge, he was convicted: he had taken ten guineas from Statham under the pretence of restoring her lace, without informing the authorities — an offence under the 1718 Act against receiving stolen goods. Sentenced to death, he attempted suicide on the morning of his execution by drinking a large dose of laudanum, but, weakened by fasting, he vomited violently and sank into a coma. He was carried to Tyburn on 24 May 1725 in a drugged stupor, accompanied by three other condemned men, and hanged before a huge crowd.

His body was buried in secret in the churchyard of St Pancras Old Church, then exhumed and sold to the Royal College of Surgeons. His skeleton remains on public display in the College’s Hunterian Museum in Lincoln’s Inn Fields.

What Wild left behind

Wild’s career did not end with his hanging. In 1728, John Gay’s The Beggar’s Opera turned Wild and Sheppard into Peachum and Macheath, and drew an unmistakable parallel between Wild and the prime minister of the day, Robert Walpole — the “Great Corrupter.” In 1743, Henry Fielding published The History of the Life of the Late Mr Jonathan Wild the Great, a satire that made Wild stand in for Walpole directly.

The more lasting consequence was practical. Wild’s trial and fall showed London, in public and in detail, how the reward system could be captured by the very criminals it was meant to catch. A thief-taker paid by results had every reason to manufacture results, and no one in authority had checked him until his own men turned on him. The scandal helped discredit private thief-taking as a way of policing a city. It would be another generation before Henry Fielding set up the Bow Street Runners in 1749, the first step toward a professional police force, and another eighty years before the Metropolitan Police was founded in 1829. But Wild’s career is the clearest early warning of what happens when the people who hunt criminals are paid like criminals’ business partners.

The victims of that system were ordinary Londoners: the shopkeepers and householders who paid Wild’s fees to get their own property back, and the thieves he sent to the gallows when they stopped being useful. Wild called himself the Thief-Taker General. The record shows he was something else — the first great organised crime boss of London, who wore the law’s uniform until the law finally noticed.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Jonathan Wild was born in Wolverhampton in 1682 or 1683, the first of five children; his father was a carpenter and his mother sold herbs and fruit. He was apprenticed to a buckle-maker, was arrested for debt in March 1710 and sent to the Wood Street Compter, and was released in 1712. He worked as an assistant to the thief-taker Charles Hitchen around 1713, then opened his own office in the Blue Boar tavern in Little Old Bailey and later in the Old Bailey. He called himself “Thief-Taker General of Great Britain and Ireland” from 1718, was consulted by the Privy Council in 1720, and by his own testimony more than sixty thieves were sent to the gallows through his evidence. Jack Sheppard was arrested by Wild’s men five times between April and November 1724 and escaped four times; Joseph “Blueskin” Blake slashed Wild’s throat in court on 15 October 1724; Blueskin was hanged on 11 November and Sheppard on 16 November 1724. Wild was arrested on 15 February 1725, tried at the Old Bailey on 15 May 1725, acquitted of stealing fifty yards of lace from Catherine Statham but convicted of taking a reward for restoring it without informing the authorities, and hanged at Tyburn on 24 May 1725. His body was buried at St Pancras Old Church, exhumed, and his skeleton is on display at the Hunterian Museum.

Unverified or unproven: The popular story that Wild kept a ledger of his thieves and marked a “double cross” against the names of those he meant to betray — the phrase “double cross” is not recorded in English until 1834, more than a century later, and the ledger story is legend, not record. Whether Wild ever turned in one of his own gang members for a private fee, as fictional treatments suggest, is not established by the record. The details of Wild’s early life, including the claim that he was born in the village of Boningale rather than Wolverhampton, rest on conflicting early accounts, and his exact birth date is unknown. Much of what is known about his private life comes from pamphlets and criminal biographies published just after his death, including Defoe’s 1725 account, which were written to sell and may have embellished or invented scenes.

Sources

Leave a Comment