In the winter of 1879, a small, limping man stood trial at Leeds Assizes for murder. Charles Peace of Sheffield was, by then, the most famous burglar in England: a picture-framer and violin dealer by day, a cat burglar by night, a master of disguise who had evaded the police for more than twenty years. He had already killed once, in Manchester, and got away with it; his second killing, of a Sheffield neighbour, brought him to the gallows at Armley Gaol.
A Sheffield childhood, a ruined leg
Charles Frederick Peace was born on 14 May 1832 in Sheffield, the youngest son of John Peace, a shoemaker, and his wife Jane, the daughter of a naval surgeon. Apprenticed in the steel trade, he was permanently injured at fourteen when a hot steel rod entered his leg in a rolling-mill accident, and he limped for the rest of his life.
The injury is often cast as the turning point of his life, but that is interpretation, not fact. What is documented is that by his early twenties he was already a thief. In 1854 he was found guilty of multiple burglaries and sentenced to four years’ penal servitude. In 1859 he married a widow, Hannah Ward; soon afterwards a major Manchester burglary, in which he nearly killed an arresting officer, earned him six years’ penal servitude.
Between sentences, Peace built a cover that served him for years: a picture-framing business and a trade in violins — he played the instrument himself, and the trade gave him a respectable reason to call on well-to-do houses and learn which were worth robbing. He was intelligent and musical — and a compulsive burglar.
The master of disguise
Peace was about five feet four, with a limp and a missing finger — marks that should have made him easy to identify. Instead he turned disguise into a craft: wigs, false beards and spectacles, dressed as clergyman, workman or gentleman, his missing finger reportedly hidden by a prosthetic hand. He used false names and moved constantly between Sheffield, Hull, Manchester, Nottingham and London.
The killing of PC Nicholas Cock
On the night of 1 August 1876, Peace was burgling in Whalley Range, Manchester, when two policemen saw him in the grounds of a house at about midnight. Police Constable Nicholas Cock intercepted him as he tried to escape. Peace drew a revolver and warned Cock to stand back, then, according to the account that has come down to us, fired deliberately wide. Cock drew his truncheon and advanced. Peace fired again, and this time the shot struck Cock, who died the following day, 2 August 1876.
Peace escaped in the dark. Police arrested two brothers who lived nearby, John and William Habron. At Manchester Assizes, John was acquitted for lack of evidence; William was found guilty and sentenced to death, later commuted to penal servitude for life.
The Habron case is the darkest part of Peace’s story: a policeman dead, an innocent man left to serve a life sentence for a murder he did not commit, while Peace, who knew the truth, said nothing for two and a half years.
The Dysons of Darnall
After the Manchester killing, Peace returned to the Sheffield suburb of Darnall, where he made the acquaintance of a civil engineer named Arthur Dyson and his wife, Katherine. Peace developed an obsessive interest in Katherine Dyson. How far she returned his feelings was never established: Peace claimed they were lovers; Katherine Dyson denied it, and her husband regarded the notes cited in support as forgeries.
What is documented is a campaign of harassment. In June 1876, Dyson threw a card into Peace’s garden reading: “Charles Peace is requested not to interfere with my family.” On 1 July, Peace allegedly threatened Katherine and her husband. Dyson took out a summons and moved his family to Banner Cross, hoping to be rid of him. On their first day in the new house, 29 November 1876, Peace found them and told Katherine: “You see, I am here to annoy you, and I’ll annoy you wherever you go.”
That evening, a little after eight o’clock, Katherine Dyson crossed the yard to the outside toilet. When she emerged, Peace confronted her with a revolver. She retreated, crying out, and her husband came out to investigate. Peace fled down the passage, Dyson following, and fired twice; the second shot struck Dyson in the head, and he died. Peace escaped by train to Hull, where his wife kept an eating-house.
Dyson had tried every lawful means — a written warning, a summons, a move across the city — to protect his wife. He died in the passage of his own new house, on his family’s first day there, because he went outside to see what was frightening his wife.
Caught at Blackheath
A hue and cry followed, with £100 on his head, but Peace was already practised at disappearing. In Nottingham he met Sue Thompson, who became his mistress. In early 1877 they moved to London, where Peace felt safer, and he sent for his wife and son Willie to join him in Peckham. Blackheath, where a rash of burglaries was noted with alarm, was among his favourite hunting grounds.
Peace was finally caught at about two in the morning on 10 October 1878, in Blackheath. Constable Edward Robinson saw a light appear suddenly in a window at the back of a house in St John’s Park. Robinson and Constable William Girling waited at the back while Sergeant Charles Brown knocked on the front door. Peace tried to escape through the garden and fired at Robinson, who held him even after a shot passed through his arm.
Peace refused to give his name for a week, but in custody he wrote a letter to a business colleague, who told police its author was Peace, writing as John Ward. Under that name he was tried at the Old Bailey for burglary and attempted murder, and sentenced by Justice Henry Hawkins to penal servitude for life. After twenty years of disguises and false names, Peace was undone by his own handwriting.
The trial at Leeds
From Pentonville, Peace was taken to Sheffield to face the Dyson murder charge. On the journey back for a second hearing, he jumped from the train near Kiveton Park and was found unconscious beside the track — or, by another account, only attempted to jump and was restrained by a warden. Either way, he was declared fit to stand trial.
His solicitor, William Clegg, argued that Mrs Dyson had been more intimate with Peace than she admitted and that Dyson had been the aggressor. She denied it, and no one could contradict her. But the prosecution’s case did not rest on her word alone: a labourer named Brassington testified that Peace had accosted him in the street, vowing to shoot “those strange folks before morning” before walking towards Dyson’s house. Brassington, a stranger to Peace, had seen him at close quarters under a gas-lamp and a full moon, and swore to his identity. The revolver taken from Peace at his arrest was produced, and the rifling marks on the bullet extracted from Dyson’s head matched it.
The trial opened on 4 February 1879 at Leeds Assizes, before Mr Justice Lopes; Thomas Campbell Foster Q.C. prosecuted, and the future Solicitor-General Frank Lockwood defended. Summing up, Lopes said it was clearly proved no struggle had taken place before the murder. Ten minutes later, the jury returned a guilty verdict. Asked if he had anything to say, Peace reportedly replied: “It is no use my saying anything.” The judge passed sentence of death, to be carried out at Armley Gaol on 25 February.
The confession and the execution
With nothing more to lose, Peace confessed to the murder of Police Constable Cock, giving details only the killer could have known. Habron was later pardoned and compensated; accounts differ on the amount (£500 and £800 are both reported), but not on the pardon.
On the morning of 25 February 1879, Peace was hanged at Armley Gaol by the executioner William Marwood, inventor of the “long drop”. He was 46, and buried within the prison. He had prepared a homemade funeral card for his wife, wrongly giving his age as 47.
Peace’s fame did not die with him: a penny dreadful was sold in a hundred weekly parts within months, and plays, films and a comic strip followed. The fascination is understandable, and worth resisting. Peace was clever, musical and daring — the qualities that make a good story. But the record is not a good story: a policeman dead doing his job, an innocent man imprisoned for a murder he did not commit, a husband dead in his own passage because he went to help his frightened wife. The disguises and the violin are the decoration. The victims are the story.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Charles Frederick Peace was born on 14 May 1832 in Sheffield and hanged at Armley Gaol, Leeds, on 25 February 1879, aged 46. He was convicted of burglary in 1854 and 1859. On 1 August 1876, in Whalley Range, Manchester, he shot Police Constable Nicholas Cock, who died the next day. John Habron was acquitted; William Habron was convicted and sentenced to death, later commuted to life imprisonment. On 29 November 1876, at Banner Cross, Sheffield, he shot Arthur Dyson, who died the same evening. Arrested at Blackheath on 10 October 1878 after shooting at Constable Edward Robinson, who survived, he was sentenced at the Old Bailey to penal servitude for life. Tried for Dyson’s murder at Leeds Assizes from 4 February 1879, he was found guilty after ten minutes and sentenced to death. Before his execution he confessed to the murder of PC Cock, and William Habron was pardoned.
Unverified or unproven: That Peace’s steelworks accident at fourteen caused his criminal career — the accident is documented, the causal link is an interpretation. That Katherine Dyson was Peace’s lover — he claimed it; she denied it, and her husband regarded the notes as forgeries; the truth was never established. That Peace fired wide of PC Cock on his first shot — Cock did not survive to give his version. Whether Peace jumped from the train near Kiveton Park or only attempted to jump — accounts differ. The compensation paid to William Habron — £500 and £800 are both reported. Peace’s age on his funeral card (47) conflicts with his documented dates (46). Longer speeches attributed to Peace should be treated as reported speech, not verbatim record.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Peace
- https://capitalpunishmentuk.org/charles-peace-an-infamous-victorian-criminal/
- https://www.calmview.eu/SheffieldArchives/CalmView/Record.aspx?src=CalmView.Catalog&id=X144&pos=2
- http://www.britishexecutions.co.uk/execution-content.php?key=1224
- https://listverse.com/2022/01/26/ten-reasons-charles-peace-was-a-most-interesting-victorian-rogue/