The Trial of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev: The Boston Marathon Bomber’s Trial

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

At 2:49 p.m. on Monday 15 April 2013, the first bomb exploded on Boylston Street in Boston, a few metres from the finish line of the Boston Marathon. Twelve seconds later, a second bomb exploded about a block away. The two blasts killed three people and injured more than 260, many of them seriously. It was the worst terrorist attack on American soil since 11 September 2001, and it set off a manhunt that shut down an entire city — and a trial, two years later, that asked whether a 21-year-old who had been 19 at the time of the bombing should be put to death.

The trial of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was held in the federal courthouse in Boston, the city that had been attacked, before a jury drawn from the people who had lived through the bombing and the lockdown that followed. It was, from the start, a case in which the question was not guilt but punishment.

The bombing and the manhunt

The Boston Marathon is one of the oldest and most famous races in the world, and Patriots’ Day, the Massachusetts holiday on which it is run, draws hundreds of thousands of spectators to the streets of Boston. On 15 April 2013, two pressure-cooker bombs, packed with nails and ball bearings and hidden in backpacks, were left near the finish line. The dead were Martin Richard, aged eight, who had been watching the race with his family; Krystle Campbell, 29, a restaurant manager from Medford; and Lu Lingzi, 23, a graduate student from China. Among the injured were 17 people who lost limbs.

Three days later, the FBI released surveillance images of two suspects, identified as “Suspect 1” and “Suspect 2”, and asked the public for help. The two men were brothers: Tamerlan Tsarnaev, 26, and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, 19, ethnic Chechens who had come to the United States as children and lived in Cambridge, Massachusetts. That night, the brothers shot dead Sean Collier, a 26-year-old police officer at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and carjacked a vehicle in Cambridge. In the early hours of 19 April, they were cornered by police in Watertown. In the shootout that followed, Tamerlan was killed — run over by his brother’s car as Dzhokhar fled — and a transit police officer was seriously wounded.

Dzhokhar escaped and hid in a boat stored in a backyard in Watertown. The authorities ordered residents of Boston and several surrounding towns to stay indoors while thousands of officers searched house by house. Late on 19 April, the boat’s owner noticed blood on the cover and called the police. Dzhokhar was found inside, wounded and hiding, and was taken into custody. He was 19 years old.

The case against him

Tsarnaev was charged in federal court with 30 counts, including using a weapon of mass destruction, bombing a place of public use, and the murder of Officer Collier. Seventeen of the counts carried the death penalty. The prosecution’s case was built on a mass of evidence: surveillance footage showing the brothers placing the backpacks, forensic evidence linking the bombs to the brothers’ apartment, and, most importantly, a note Tsarnaev had written inside the boat while he was hiding, in which he said the bombings were retaliation for the United States’ wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and described the victims as “collateral damage”.

His defence team, led by Judy Clarke, one of America’s best-known death penalty lawyers, did not seriously contest that he had taken part in the bombing. Instead, they argued that Dzhokhar had been dominated and led by his older brother, Tamerlan, who was the driving force behind the attack. They described Dzhokhar as a follower — a young man who had been a normal, popular student at the University of Massachusetts Dartmouth, who had fallen under his brother’s influence. The strategy was aimed at the penalty phase: if the jury believed Dzhokhar was less culpable than his brother, they might spare his life.

The trial began in January 2015, almost two years after the bombing, in the John Joseph Moakley United States Courthouse in Boston. Jury selection alone took two months. The defence had asked for the trial to be moved out of Boston, arguing that no jury in the city could be impartial, but the judge refused. The prosecution called 92 witnesses, including survivors who described their injuries in detail, and the court saw photographs and video of the bombing that had never been shown in public. Tsarnaev himself said nothing throughout the trial, and showed little visible reaction to the evidence.

Guilty on all counts

On 8 April 2015, after eleven hours of deliberation, the jury found Tsarnaev guilty on all 30 counts. The penalty phase began a week later. The prosecution argued that the bombing was a deliberate act of terrorism, that Tsarnaev had shown no remorse, and that he remained a danger. They played a video of him placing the backpack, and they called the families of the three people who had been killed. The defence called his teachers, friends, and family members, who described a quiet, friendly young man, and they argued that his youth and his brother’s influence should count in his favour.

On 15 May 2015, the jury sentenced Dzhokhar Tsarnaev to death. He was 21 years old. In June 2015, the judge formally imposed the sentence, telling Tsarnaev: “No one will remember that your teachers were fond of you, that you were funny, a good athlete. You will be remembered for the terrible things you did.” Tsarnaev, speaking for the first time in the proceedings, apologised to the victims and their families, saying he was sorry for the lives he had taken and the suffering he had caused, and asking for forgiveness. He was sent to the federal supermax prison in Florence, Colorado, to await execution.

The appeals — and the death sentence that came back

Tsarnaev’s case did not end with the sentence. In July 2020, a panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit vacated the death sentence, ruling that the trial judge had not done enough to screen prospective jurors for bias and had wrongly excluded some evidence about Tamerlan’s past. The court left the convictions in place but ordered a new penalty-phase trial to decide the sentence again.

The federal government appealed, and on 4 March 2022 the Supreme Court of the United States reversed the First Circuit by a vote of six to three, reinstating the death sentence. The majority held that the trial judge had acted within his discretion in the way he had handled jury selection, and that the excluded evidence had been properly kept out. The decision returned Tsarnaev to death row, where he remains. No execution date has been set, and the federal government has not carried out an execution since 2021.

What the trial showed

The trial of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev raised questions that have no easy answers. The first was about the death penalty itself. Massachusetts abolished the death penalty in 1984, and the state has not executed anyone since 1947. Yet Tsarnaev was tried in federal court, where the death penalty was available, and the jury — drawn from a state that had rejected capital punishment — imposed it. Several of the victims’ families were divided on the question: some supported the death sentence, while others, including the parents of Martin Richard, publicly asked the government to take the death penalty off the table and accept a sentence of life without parole, arguing that years of appeals would only prolong their suffering.

The second question was about Dzhokhar himself. He was 19 when he planted the bomb, and the defence’s argument — that he was a follower, not a leader — divided opinion. The jury rejected it. But the note he wrote in the boat, the surveillance footage, and the testimony of those who knew him left a picture that was genuinely difficult to reconcile: a young man who had been, by many accounts, an ordinary student, who had taken part in an act of extraordinary cruelty, and who showed remorse only after he had been sentenced to die.

The third question was about the city. Boston’s response to the bombing — the lockdown, the manhunt, the phrase “Boston Strong” that appeared on signs and shirts across the city — became part of the trial’s backdrop. The prosecution’s case was, in part, an argument that the bombing had been an attack on the city itself, and the jury’s verdict was, in part, the city’s answer.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: On 15 April 2013, two bombs exploded near the finish line of the Boston Marathon, killing Martin Richard, Krystle Campbell, and Lu Lingzi, and injuring more than 260 people. Tamerlan Tsarnaev was killed in a shootout with police on 19 April 2013, and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was captured the same day. At his trial in Boston in 2015 he was convicted on all 30 counts, and on 15 May 2015 he was sentenced to death. The First Circuit vacated the death sentence in July 2020, and the Supreme Court reinstated it on 4 March 2022 by a vote of six to three. Tsarnaev remains on death row at the federal supermax prison in Florence, Colorado.

Unverified or unproven: That Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was radicalised by his older brother alone — the defence argued that Tamerlan was the driving force, but the extent of outside influence on either brother has never been fully established. Claims that the brothers acted on behalf of a foreign organisation have not been substantiated; the authorities concluded that they acted independently. Any suggestion that the police response to the manhunt involved excessive force is a matter of public debate, not a finding of any court.

Sources

Leave a Comment