At about 4 a.m. on December 17, 1968, someone knocked on the door of a room at the Rodeway Inn in Decatur, Georgia. Inside were Barbara Jane Mackle, a 20-year-old student at Emory University, and her mother, Jane, who had travelled from Florida to nurse her daughter through a bad case of influenza. The caller said he was a police officer and that Barbara’s boyfriend had been in a traffic accident. When the door opened, the two people outside were wearing ski masks. One of them was armed with a shotgun.
Within minutes, Jane Mackle had been chloroformed, bound, and gagged. Barbara, in her nightgown, was forced at gunpoint into the back of a waiting car and driven away. She would spend the next three and a half days buried underground in a pine forest, in a box built by her kidnapper, while her family and the FBI raced to find her alive.
A Box Built for the Crime
The kidnappers were Gary Steven Krist, a 23-year-old prison escapee, and Ruth Eisemann-Schier, a 26-year-old graduate student from Honduras. Krist had escaped from a California prison in 1966 and was living under the alias George Deacon, working as a technician at the University of Miami’s Institute of Marine Science. Eisemann-Schier was studying there. The pair had planned the crime carefully, and Krist had used his workshop skills to build the capsule in which Barbara would be held.
They drove her about 20 miles to a remote pine stand off South Berkeley Lake Road in Gwinnett County, near Duluth, Georgia. There, in a shallow trench, sat a box roughly seven feet long, three feet wide, and three and a half feet deep, built of plywood and lined with fibreglass. It was fitted with a battery-powered lamp, a ventilation system with an air pump, water, and food. Before she was placed inside, Krist made Barbara hold a hand-lettered sign reading “KIDNAPPED” and photographed her with a Polaroid camera. Then the lid went on, the screws went in, and earth was shovelled over the top.
The kidnappers demanded a ransom of $500,000 from Barbara’s father, Robert Mackle, a wealthy Florida land developer. Over December 17 and 18, the money was gathered in twenty-dollar bills, placed in a suitcase, and delivered as instructed. Krist and Eisemann-Schier collected it, but they did not release Barbara. They returned to their motel, checked out, and began the long drive back toward Miami, listening to radio bulletins about the kidnapping they had committed.
The Car That Gave Them Away
The investigation turned on a car. A blue Volvo seen near the Rodeway Inn was traced, and inside it investigators found photographs and a registration in the name of George Deacon. The FBI traced Deacon to the University of Miami, where they discovered that he built ventilated boxes at the Institute of Marine Science. Letters addressed to Deacon and to Gary Krist led agents to compare fingerprints, and the comparison showed that Deacon and Krist were the same man — an escaped prisoner.
Meanwhile, Barbara was alone underground, in darkness, with only the lamp and the sound of the air pump for company. She had been given instructions on how to operate the equipment inside the box. She was severely dehydrated and growing weaker, but she stayed alive.
On December 20, Krist telephoned an FBI switchboard operator and gave vague directions to the burial site. Agents searched the pine stand off South Berkeley Lake Road and found the box. When they lifted the lid, Barbara was alive. She had been underground for roughly 83 hours. She was dehydrated, had lost weight, and was too weak to stand, but she was otherwise unharmed.
Arrests, Trials, and Aftermaths
Krist was arrested on December 21, 1968, after a search that ran through the night. FBI agents spotted his boat from a Coast Guard aircraft near Fort Myers, Florida, and found a duffel bag aboard containing $479,000 of the ransom money in twenty-dollar bills. Eisemann-Schier remained at large for more than two months. She was arrested on March 5, 1969, in Norman, Oklahoma, and became the first woman ever added to the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list.
Both pleaded guilty. Krist was convicted in 1969 and sentenced to life in prison, but was released on parole after ten years, in 1979. Eisemann-Schier was convicted and sentenced to seven years, paroled after serving four, and deported to her native Honduras.
Barbara Mackle told her own story in a book written with Miami Herald reporter Gene Miller, “83 Hours Till Dawn,” published in 1971. It became the basis of two television movies. Krist also wrote a book about the crime, “Life: The Man Who Kidnapped Barbara Jane Mackle,” published in 1972.
Krist’s later life returned him to the headlines. In March 2006, he was arrested on a sailboat off the coast of Alabama with 14 kilograms of cocaine, reportedly worth about $1 million, and four undocumented people aboard. In August 2012, a federal judge in Mobile, Alabama, revoked his supervised release for violating his probation.
The Mackle case endures because of what it revealed: a crime planned with technical ingenuity, a victim who survived by endurance, and an investigation that turned on a single car and a set of fingerprints. It also endures as a reminder that the most dangerous moment in a kidnapping is often not the abduction itself, but the long silence that follows it.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: The abduction on December 17, 1968, at the Rodeway Inn in Decatur; the identities of Krist and Eisemann-Schier; the $500,000 ransom demand and its payment; the discovery and rescue of Barbara Mackle on December 20, 1968, after approximately 83 hours underground; Krist’s arrest on December 21, 1968, and the recovery of $479,000 from his boat; Eisemann-Schier’s arrest on March 5, 1969; the convictions and sentences of both; Krist’s 2006 drug arrest and 2012 revocation of supervised release; and Mackle’s book “83 Hours Till Dawn.”
Disputed or uncertain: Sources differ on the exact location of the burial site, described variously as near Duluth and near Lawrenceville, both in Gwinnett County. Some secondary accounts give Krist’s arrest date as December 20 rather than December 21. This article follows the Wikipedia account and the Georgia court record, which place the arrest on December 21, but the discrepancy is noted here.
Unverified: Some popular retellings add details about the kidnappers’ movements and conversations that do not appear in the court record or the FBI account. This article relies on the documented record and does not repeat them.