The Connecticut River Valley Killer is the name given to an unidentified killer believed to be responsible for at least seven murders of women in New Hampshire and Vermont between 1978 and 1988. The victims were found in wooded areas and along rural roads near the Connecticut River, the waterway that forms the border between the two states. No one has ever been charged with any of the murders, and the case remains open in both states.
It is important to say at the outset what investigators themselves have said: it has never been conclusively proved that a single person committed every murder grouped under this name. The individual cases remain separate unsolved investigations. What links them is a pattern — women travelling alone, attacked with a knife, their bodies left in remote places within a relatively small area — and a decade in which the killings stopped as suddenly as they began.
The First Victim
The earliest murder generally associated with the series was that of Catherine “Cathy” Millican, aged 27, of New London, New Hampshire. On 24 October 1978, Millican left work and went to the Chandler Brook Wetland Preserve, where she was photographing birds. She was last seen that afternoon near the entrance to the wetlands off Route 11. Her body was found the following day, several hundred yards into the woods, bearing multiple stab wounds. Millican worked in the marketing department of a publishing company and lived in nearby Sunapee.
Nearly three years passed before the next murder linked to the series. On 25 July 1981, Mary Elizabeth “Betsy” Critchley, aged 37, a student at the University of Vermont, was dropped off by a friend near Exit 13 of the Massachusetts Turnpike. She planned to hitchhike north to her home in Waterbury, Vermont. On 9 August, her body was found in a wooded area off Unity Stage Road in Unity, New Hampshire, about eighty miles from where she had last been seen.
The Middle Years
On 30 May 1984, Bernice Courtemanche, a 17-year-old high school student and part-time nurse’s aide, was last seen in Claremont, New Hampshire. Her skeletal remains were found in 1986 near the Sugar River in Newport, New Hampshire, bearing evidence of knife wounds.
On 10 July 1985, Eva Marie Morse, aged 27, a single mother, was last seen hitchhiking along Route 12 in North Charlestown, New Hampshire. Her remains were found the following spring in the woods in Unity, New Hampshire, not far from where Critchley’s body had been discovered. The remains of Courtemanche and Morse were recovered within about a thousand feet of each other, in a wooded area in Kelleyville, New Hampshire, according to investigators.
The pattern changed, briefly, in 1986. On 15 April 1986, Lynda Moore, aged 36, was killed inside her own home in Saxtons River, Vermont, near Route 121. She had been doing yard work outside the house that afternoon while her husband was at work. He returned home that evening to find her body in the living room. Unlike the other victims, Moore was not taken from a roadside or a public place. The attack inside her home showed that the killer, whoever he was, was willing to strike where a victim lived.
The last murder in the series was that of Barbara Agnew, aged 38, a nurse at Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center in Lebanon, New Hampshire. On 10 January 1987, Agnew went skiing with friends at Stratton Mountain in Vermont and drove home toward Norwich, Vermont, that evening. Her green BMW was later found at a northbound Interstate 91 rest area in Hartford, Vermont, with blood inside the vehicle. Her body was discovered on 28 March 1987 in a wooded area near Advent Hill Road in Hartland, Vermont, about twelve miles from the rest area.
The Woman Who Survived
Late in the evening of 6 August 1988, Jane Boroski, aged 22 and seven months pregnant, was returning from the Cheshire County Fair in Keene, New Hampshire, when she stopped at a closed convenience store in West Swanzey to buy a drink from a vending machine. A man approached her car, asked about a payphone, and then attacked her. She was stabbed twenty-seven times and left for dead. Boroski survived, and so did her baby. She managed to drive herself to a friend’s house for help, and she later gave investigators a description of her attacker, a composite sketch, and the first characters of his vehicle’s licence plate. The vehicle was described as a Jeep Wagoneer.
Boroski’s survival gave investigators their only eyewitness account in the entire series, and it remains the most valuable single piece of evidence in the case. After her attack, the killings attributed to the Connecticut River Valley Killer stopped. No further murders in the pattern have been recorded.
The Investigation
At the height of the investigation, detectives from New Hampshire and Vermont worked together, noting similarities in the way the victims were attacked, the places their bodies were left, and the wounds they suffered. But the evidence never produced a suspect who could be charged. The cases were spread across two states, several counties, and a decade, and forensic science in the 1970s and 1980s could not do what it can do today.
One name has been publicly associated with the case. In October 1997, a man named Gary Westover told his uncle, a retired sheriff’s deputy, that in 1987 he had been taken along when three men abducted and murdered Barbara Agnew. One of the men he named was Michael Nicholaou. Westover died in March 1998 before his account could be fully tested. Nicholaou was later shown to Boroski in a photograph line-up, and reports at the time said she recognised him as her attacker. But Nicholaou was never charged with any Connecticut River Valley murder, and Boroski has since said in interviews that she does not believe Nicholaou was the man who attacked her. The Nicholaou theory has never been proved.
Investigators have continued to revisit the evidence as forensic technology has improved. In May 2024, police searched a home in Newport, New Hampshire, near where Bernice Courtemanche’s remains were found, for evidence relating to the Connecticut River Valley murders. No charges resulted from that search.
The New Hampshire Attorney General’s Office and the Vermont State Police have both said the cases remain open. The women at the centre of them — Millican, Critchley, Courtemanche, Morse, Moore and Agnew — were nurses, students, mothers and neighbours, and their families have waited decades for answers that have not come.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: At least seven women were killed in the Connecticut River Valley region of New Hampshire and Vermont between 1978 and 1987. Six of the victims are documented in detail in the sources consulted: Catherine Millican (1978), Betsy Critchley (1981), Bernice Courtemanche (1984), Eva Morse (1985), Lynda Moore (1986) and Barbara Agnew (1987). Jane Boroski, aged 22 and seven months pregnant, survived an attack on 6 August 1988 in West Swanzey, New Hampshire, and gave investigators a description, a composite sketch and a partial licence plate. No one has been charged with any of the murders, and the cases remain open in both states.
Not established: That a single killer committed all of the murders. Law enforcement has cautioned against assuming that every case grouped under the name was committed by the same person, and the linkage has never been proved. The seventh victim most often listed in accounts of the series is Ellen Ruth Fried, aged 26, but the sources consulted for this article did not provide verified details of her case, so they are not stated here. The claim that Michael Nicholaou was the killer rests on an uncorroborated account from a witness who died before it could be tested, and the surviving victim has since cast doubt on it. Nicholaou was never charged.