In the spring of 1924, Chicago was shaken by a crime that seemed to defy explanation. The killers were not desperate men driven by need or revenge. They were two gifted university students from wealthy, respected families — and they said they had killed simply to see whether they could commit the perfect crime and get away with it. The boy they killed was 14-year-old Bobby Franks, a neighbour and a cousin of one of them. The trial that followed became one of the most famous in American history — not because guilt was in doubt, since both confessed, but because their lawyer, Clarence Darrow, turned it into an argument against the death penalty itself.
Two Students and a “Perfect Crime”
Nathan Leopold Jr., 19, and Richard Loeb, 18, were students at the University of Chicago. Leopold, born on 19 November 1904, had graduated with Phi Beta Kappa honours and planned to study law at Harvard. Loeb, born on 11 June 1905, had graduated from the University of Michigan at 17, reportedly its youngest graduate at the time. Both came from wealthy Chicago families and lived in the affluent Kenwood neighbourhood on the city’s South Side.
According to their confessions and the psychiatric reports prepared for the defence, the two had spent about seven months planning a “perfect crime”: the kidnapping and killing of a younger boy from a wealthy family, followed by a ransom demand to mislead investigators about their motive. Leopold linked their sense of being above ordinary rules to Friedrich Nietzsche’s concept of the “superman” — his own interpretation, not a fair summary of Nietzsche’s work.
On the afternoon of 21 May 1924, they drove a rented car, hired under a false name, around Kenwood looking for a victim. They spotted Bobby Franks, the 14-year-old son of wealthy watch manufacturer Jacob Franks, walking home from school. Franks was a neighbour and a distant cousin of Loeb’s; they offered him a ride, and he accepted.
The Killing and the Ransom Note
Bobby Franks was struck in the head and killed inside the car. The two men hid the body in a remote culvert beside Pennsylvania Railroad tracks near Wolf Lake, south of Chicago, pouring hydrochloric acid on it to delay identification. They then mailed a typed ransom note to Jacob Franks demanding $10,000, and telephoned the family to say the boy was safe.
The plan unravelled within a day: on the morning of 22 May, a workman noticed a foot protruding from the culvert, and the body was found. The case was now a murder investigation.
A Pair of Glasses Undoes the Plan
The decisive clue was small. Near the body, investigators found a pair of horn-rimmed eyeglasses fitted with an unusual hinge. The optometrist told police only three Chicago customers had bought that style — one was Nathan Leopold. Questioned, Leopold said he must have lost the glasses during a birdwatching trip near the culvert; he was a keen ornithologist.
The alibi did not hold: the family’s chauffeur said he had been repairing Leopold’s own car that afternoon, and reporters found Leopold’s typewriter was an Underwood — the make used for the ransom note. It was recovered from Jackson Park Lagoon on 7 June.
On 31 May, ten days after the killing, both young men confessed. Each blamed the other for striking the fatal blows — a point on which their accounts disagreed, and which has remained disputed. Most contemporary observers believed Loeb had struck the blows, a view later supported by defence evidence that Loeb had washed blood from his hands at the culvert. Neither man denied that they had planned the killing together, and both said they had done it for the thrill of the experience.
Darrow’s Gamble: Pleading Guilty
With the confessions in hand, State’s Attorney Robert E. Crowe sought the death penalty. The families hired Clarence Darrow, then 67 and already the most famous criminal defence lawyer in America, a lifelong opponent of capital punishment. Darrow made a decision that stunned the courtroom when the case opened before Judge John R. Caverly on 23 July 1924: he had both defendants withdraw their not-guilty pleas and plead guilty to murder and kidnapping.
The move removed the jury from the case entirely. With guilt admitted, the only question left was the sentence, and that would be decided by a single judge. Darrow then spent weeks presenting psychiatric evidence — not to argue his clients were legally insane, which the doctors did not support, but to argue that their youth and disturbed mental states should weigh against execution.
Darrow’s closing plea, delivered in late August, ran for hours and is still regarded as one of the great speeches in American legal history. He asked why the two had killed Bobby Franks, and answered his own question: they had killed him, he said, “as they might kill a spider or a fly, for the experience. They killed him because they were made that way.” His argument was not that they were innocent, but that youth, a flawed upbringing and mental disturbance called for mercy rather than vengeance — and that the death penalty itself was a relic of barbarism.
The Sentence and What Followed
Judge Caverly took more than two weeks to decide. On 10 September 1924, he sentenced Leopold and Loeb each to life imprisonment for murder, plus 99 years for kidnapping. In his reasoning, he said he was moved chiefly by the age of the defendants — 18 and 19 at the time of the crime.
Both were sent to prison at Joliet. Richard Loeb was killed by a fellow prisoner on 28 January 1936. Nathan Leopold remained in prison for more than three decades; after the Second World War, Governor Adlai Stevenson reduced his sentence in recognition of his volunteer work in wartime malaria testing, making him eligible for parole. Leopold was released in 1958, moved to Puerto Rico, and died there on 29 August 1971.
What the record shows
- On 21 May 1924, Nathan Leopold, 19, and Richard Loeb, 18, killed 14-year-old Bobby Franks in Chicago. Both confessed on 31 May 1924, each blaming the other for the fatal blows — a detail that remains disputed.
- A pair of eyeglasses with an unusual hinge, traced to Leopold, and a typewriter recovered from Jackson Park Lagoon were the key physical evidence linking them to the crime.
- On Darrow’s advice, both pleaded guilty. Judge John R. Caverly sentenced each to life imprisonment plus 99 years on 10 September 1924, citing their youth as the decisive factor.
- Loeb was killed in prison in 1936. Leopold was paroled in 1958 and died in Puerto Rico in 1971.
- The trial’s lasting significance is Darrow’s argument against capital punishment, delivered in a case where guilt was never in dispute and only the sentence was at stake.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leopold_and_Loeb
- https://www.encyclopedia.com/law/law-magazines/leopold-and-loeb-trial-1924
- https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/leopold-and-loebs-criminal-minds-996498/
- https://www.northwestern.edu/magazine/winter2011/feature/full-of-drama-sidebar/crime-of-the-century.html