In the summer of 1918, New Orleans was already a city under strain, with the First World War in its final months and the influenza pandemic beginning its deadly sweep. Into that fear came another: an intruder who broke into homes at night, attacked sleeping families with an axe — often their own axe — and vanished without leaving a trace.
The newspapers called him the Axeman. Between May 1918 and October 1919, at least six people were killed and several more were seriously injured in attacks attributed to him. He was never caught, never identified, and the attacks stopped as suddenly as they had begun. A century later, historians still disagree about which attacks belong to a single killer, and whether the most famous piece of evidence in the case — a letter promising mercy to anyone playing jazz — was written by the killer at all.
The first attacks
The first attack attributed to the Axeman came on the night of 22–23 May 1918. Joseph Maggio, an Italian grocer, and his wife Catherine were attacked while asleep in their apartment above their grocery at the corner of Upperline and Magnolia Streets. Both had their throats cut with a straight razor, and both were then struck with an axe. Catherine died at the scene. Joseph survived the attack itself but died shortly after being found by his brothers. The axe used in the attack belonged to the household.
A city in fear
By the autumn of 1918, the attacks had made the Axeman a household name in New Orleans. Doors were barricaded at night, and families slept in shifts. The police, under Superintendent Frank T. Cannizzaro, had almost nothing to work with: no fingerprints, no description of the intruder that could be relied on, and no clear motive. The axe was usually left behind, and it usually belonged to the victim’s own household. There was no sign of robbery in most of the attacks. Several people were picked up on suspicion and released.
A month after the Maggios, on the night of 27 June, grocer Louis Besumer and his common-law wife Harriet Anna Lowe were attacked in their rooms behind Besumer’s grocery. Besumer survived with a fractured skull. Lowe was left with lasting injuries, including partial paralysis of her face; she died on 5 August. Besumer himself was charged with her murder — a reminder of how thin the evidence was, and how readily suspicion fell on the survivors. He was acquitted in 1919. On 5 August, Mary Schneider, who was pregnant, was attacked in her home while her husband was away; she survived and described a tall, dark figure. Five days later, Joseph Romano, an elderly man, was attacked in his home and died two days later.
The victims in these early attacks were, for the most part, Italian immigrants who ran small grocery stores — a pattern that shaped both the fear in the city and the way the case was reported. But not every attack fit the pattern, and not every attack on an Italian grocer in those years was necessarily the work of the same person. That uncertainty runs through the whole case. The investigation was also complicated by the fact that New Orleans in 1918 was a city where violent crime was not uncommon, and where some killings may have been settled scores dressed up as the work of a single phantom. Sorting the Axeman’s attacks from other violence of the period is one of the reasons the official count of victims varies so widely — from six killed in the most conservative accounting to as many as seventeen in the broadest.
The jazz letter
On 13 March 1919, New Orleans newspapers published a letter purporting to be from the Axeman, dated from “Hell” and signed “The Axeman.” The writer described himself as a spirit and a demon from the hottest hell, invisible and in close relationship with the Angel of Death. Then came the proposition that made the letter famous: at 12:15 a.m. on the following Tuesday night, 19 March, he would pass over New Orleans — but every person would be spared in whose home a jazz band was in full swing at that hour.
The city responded as the letter seemed to invite. On the night of 19 March, jazz poured out of homes, bars and dance halls across New Orleans, and professional bands were hired to play through the night. No murders occurred that night. Some took that as proof the letter was genuine. Others, then and since, have taken it as proof of nothing at all — a night without a murder was, after all, the normal state of affairs.
The authorship of the letter is disputed. Historians generally doubt that the killer wrote it. The letter’s polished, theatrical language sits oddly beside the silence and speed of the attacks, and no evidence has ever connected it to the person who broke into those houses. Modern attempts to test the letter, including DNA work reported in 2018, have not produced a match or an identification. The letter should therefore be treated as what it is: a document published in the newspapers, of unknown authorship, that became part of the legend.
The last attacks
The attacks did not stop with the letter. On the night of 10 March 1919 — three days before the letter was published — Charles Cortimiglia, his wife Rosie and their infant daughter Mary were attacked in their home in Gretna, across the Mississippi from New Orleans. Charles and Rosie survived with serious head injuries; their daughter Mary was killed. Local authorities arrested two neighbours, Iorlando Jordano and his teenage son Frank, as suspects, and whether the Cortimiglia attack was the Axeman’s work at all has been debated ever since.
The last attack attributed to the Axeman came on the night of 27 October 1919. Mike Pepitone was struck in his bedroom in his flat on Corrado Street; his wife, woken by a noise, arrived at the door just as a large man carrying an axe was fleeing. Pepitone died of his injuries.
After that, the attacks stopped. The killer — if there was one killer — was never caught and never identified.
The same caution applies to the suspects proposed over the years. Crime writer Colin Wilson suggested that the Axeman might have been a man named Joseph Momfre (also spelled Mumfre), said to have been shot dead in Los Angeles in 1920 by the widow of Mike Pepitone. Later researchers found no evidence that such a person existed, and the theory is now generally regarded as unproven — some researchers describe it as an urban legend. No suspect in the case was ever charged with the Axeman attacks as a series, and no one should be presented as the Axeman on the basis of speculation.
What the record shows
What is documented is this: between May 1918 and October 1919, a series of night-time attacks on sleeping households in New Orleans and Gretna left at least six people dead and several more seriously injured; the intruder typically forced entry, used an axe or hatchet — often the household’s own — and left no usable description or fingerprint; a letter purporting to be from the killer was published on 13 March 1919, promising to spare homes playing jazz on the night of 19 March, and no attack occurred that night; and the last attack attributed to the series, the killing of Mike Pepitone, took place on 27 October 1919, after which the attacks stopped and no one was ever identified or charged.
What is disputed is how many of the attacks were committed by one person, whether the Pepitone killing and later Louisiana attacks belong to the same series, who wrote the jazz letter, and who the Axeman was. The name endures, and the jazz letter is still quoted, but the identity behind them remains unknown — and the victims, most of them Italian immigrant shopkeepers and their families, remain the centre of a case that the city never solved.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axeman_of_New_Orleans
- https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/axeman-new-orleans-preyed-italian-immigrants-180968037/
- https://www.openculture.com/2018/10/story-axeman-new-orleans-serial-killer-loved-jazz.html
- https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmXoypizjW3WknFiJnKLwHCnL72vedxjQkDDP1mXWo6uco/wiki/The_Axeman_of_New_Orleans.html
- https://dyerbolical.com/the-axeman-of-new-orleans-shadowy-precursor-to-modern-serial-terror/