On 25 February 1957, a child’s body was found in a wooded area off Susquehanna Road in the Fox Chase neighbourhood of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The boy, naked and wrapped in a blanket, had been placed inside a cardboard box that had once held a baby’s bassinet, sold by J. C. Penney. He was small, thin, and showed signs of having been badly hurt and poorly nourished. He was about four years old.
No one came forward to claim him. No missing-child report matched him. For more than sixty-five years he was known only as the Boy in the Box, and as America’s Unknown Child. In December 2022, investigators finally gave him his name: Joseph Augustus Zarelli, born 13 January 1953. His killer has never been identified, and the case remains an open homicide investigation.
The discovery
The body was found on a cold February day in a patch of woods beside the road. The box had been left in the brush, partly hidden. Police determined that the boy had died from blunt force trauma, and that his death was a homicide. He had, in the judgement of the medical examiner, suffered repeated harm before he died, and he had not been adequately fed. The details of his condition are recorded in the case file; they are painful, and they are the reason the case stayed in public memory for so long.
Investigators estimated his age at between three and seven years old. He had fair hair and blue eyes. His hands and feet were wrinkled, as if he had been in water, and his body showed signs of having been recently washed. Fingerprints were taken, and his footprints were compared with hospital records in the area. Posters bearing a photograph of the boy — taken after death, as was the practice of the time — were distributed widely, and the case was given extensive newspaper coverage. Thousands of tips came in. None of them led to an identification.
The box itself was traced to a J. C. Penney bassinet, but the store’s records did not narrow the search to a buyer. A blanket found with the body was of a type made in quantity and sold widely. The roads around Fox Chase were checked, neighbours were interviewed, and hospitals, orphanages and schools were asked about missing children. Nothing matched.
Buried without a name
With no family to claim him, the boy was buried in a potter’s field — the section of a cemetery reserved for the unidentified and the poor. For decades, visitors left flowers and toys at the grave of America’s Unknown Child. In time a headstone was placed there bearing that name, and the grave became a place of quiet public remembrance: a child no one had claimed, remembered by strangers.
The case never fully left the Philadelphia Police Department’s files. Detectives revisited it periodically, and in the 1990s and 2000s new forensic techniques offered a new route. In 1998, the boy’s body was exhumed so that DNA could be extracted from his remains. A basic DNA profile was created, but at the time it produced no match and no identification. The science was not yet able to do what the case needed.
Theories that led nowhere
Over the decades, several theories about who had hurt Joseph were put forward. One of the best known came from a woman who told investigators that her mother had bought the boy from his birth parents and kept him in a basement, and that he had died after being punished. Her account was investigated, but it was never corroborated, and no charges were ever brought on the basis of it. It remains an unproven claim, not a finding.
Other suggestions — that the boy had been placed in foster care, or that he had been abandoned by a family that had since moved away — were likewise never established. The record supports only this: a four-year-old boy from West Philadelphia died violently in the winter of 1957, and the people who knew him did not come forward, or were not found.
It is important to be clear about what the identification did and did not change. Naming Joseph did not name a killer. Philadelphia police have said they have suspicions about who may have been responsible, but they have not shared them, and no suspect has been publicly named or charged. Anyone named in speculation online should be treated as exactly that — speculation — until police say otherwise.
The science that gave him his name
The turning point came in 2019, when the Philadelphia Police Department’s Office of Forensic Science, which had set up a forensic genealogy programme, exhumed Joseph’s body a second time. The DNA recovered in 1998 had proved insufficient for modern analysis, and the remains had degraded badly over six decades in the ground. Forensic genealogists described the DNA as severely fragmented, and extracting a usable profile took years.
Scientists at Identifinders International, working with the police department, sent samples to specialist laboratories, including the International Commission on Missing Persons in The Hague and the Max Planck Institute in Leipzig, Germany. Eventually a genetic profile suitable for forensic investigative genetic genealogy was produced and uploaded to public genealogy databases. By tracing third and fourth cousins, genealogists built a family tree that led to Joseph’s birth parents in West Philadelphia. DNA testing of living relatives on both sides of the family confirmed the match, and a birth certificate was located for a boy born on 13 January 1953 whose parents matched the genealogical findings.
On 8 December 2022, Philadelphia Police Commissioner Danielle Outlaw announced at a press conference that the Boy in the Box had a name: Joseph Augustus Zarelli. His birth certificate now bears his name, and his death certificate has been amended to reflect it. Police confirmed that his birth parents are both deceased, and that he has living siblings on both sides of his family, whose names have not been released. The identification was the first made through the Philadelphia Police Department’s forensic genealogy programme, and it was achieved only after two exhumations and years of laboratory work on badly degraded DNA.
What the record shows
What is documented is this: on 25 February 1957, the body of a four-year-old boy was found in a cardboard bassinet box in Fox Chase, Philadelphia; the medical examiner determined that he died by homicide, from blunt force trauma, after a period of poor nourishment and repeated harm; no missing-child report matched him, and he remained unidentified for sixty-five years; his body was exhumed in 1998 and again in 2019 for DNA testing; and on 8 December 2022, forensic investigative genetic genealogy identified him as Joseph Augustus Zarelli, born 13 January 1953 in West Philadelphia.
What is not documented is who hurt him, where exactly he spent the last months of his life, or why no one reported him missing. Those questions remain open, and the Philadelphia Police Department still treats the case as an active homicide investigation. Joseph waited sixty-five years for his name. The search for the person responsible for his death continues.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Joseph_Augustus_Zarelli
- https://www.forensicmag.com/592658-BREAKING-Boy-in-the-Box-is-Joseph-Augustus-Zarelli/
- https://www.aetv.com/articles/how-authorities-identified-the-boy-in-the-box-after-65-years
- https://identifinders.com/the-boy-in-the-box/
- https://www.gsnsp.com/joseph-augustus-zarelli-dna-boy-in-the-box/