Willie Sutton: The Gentleman Bank Robber

Reading Time: 8 minutes ·

On 18 February 1952, a young Brooklyn clothing salesman named Arnold Schuster was riding the subway when he spotted a familiar face across the carriage. The man was small, neatly dressed, and unremarkable — exactly the way he liked it. Schuster, an amateur criminologist, recognised him as Willie Sutton, one of the first names ever placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list. He followed Sutton off the train and alerted two patrolling police officers. Minutes later, the most famous bank robber in America was under arrest for the last time, caught because he had stopped to deal with a dead car battery.

It was a quiet, almost ordinary ending to an extraordinary criminal career. Over roughly forty years, Sutton robbed an estimated one hundred banks and stole an estimated two million dollars. He escaped from three prisons and spent more than half of his adult life behind bars. And through it all, he never killed anyone — a fact that, combined with his manners and his disguises, turned a career criminal into a folk hero of sorts. The newspapers called him “Willie the Actor” and “Slick Willie.” Sutton himself, in the memoirs he wrote late in life, offered a simpler explanation for his career: he enjoyed it.

A Brooklyn boyhood

William Francis Sutton Jr. was born on 30 June 1901 in Brooklyn, New York, into an Irish-American family. His father, William Francis Sutton Sr., was a blacksmith; his mother was Mary Ellen Bowles. The family lived in Irishtown, Brooklyn, now Vinegar Hill, and moved to High Street when Sutton was three. He was the fourth of five children, and he left school after the eighth grade.

Sutton drifted into crime young, starting with small thefts and graduating to burglary and safe-cracking; his longest period of legal employment lasted eighteen months. He married Louise Leudemann in 1929; their daughter Jeanie was born the following year, and Louise divorced him while he was in prison. He married a second time, to Olga Kowalska, in 1933.

What set Sutton apart was not violence but preparation. He studied banks the way an actor studies a part, arriving shortly before opening time, when staff were unlocking doors and counting cash, and walking in wearing the uniform of someone who belonged there. Over the years his disguises included a postman, a police officer, a messenger, a maintenance man, and a postal telegraph messenger — the last worn for a Broadway jewellery store robbery carried out in broad daylight. He usually carried a pistol or a Thompson submachine gun, but in an interview published in Reader’s Digest shortly before his death, he said he never carried a loaded gun, because somebody might get hurt. He was, by most accounts, unfailingly polite during robberies, and was said never to proceed if a woman screamed or a baby cried — a claim that is widely repeated but rests on anecdote rather than any official record.

The Sing Sing escape

Sentenced to thirty years in Sing Sing prison at Ossining, New York, in June 1931 for assault and robbery, he served barely eighteen months of it. On 11 December 1932, using a smuggled gun, he took a prison guard hostage and, with the guard as leverage, obtained a forty-five-foot ladder to scale the thirty-foot wall of the prison grounds.

On 15 February 1933, Sutton attempted to rob the Corn Exchange Bank and Trust Company in Philadelphia, entering disguised as a postman, but an alert passerby foiled the attempt. Undeterred, he returned to the same bank on 15 January 1934, breaking in through a skylight with two companions. His luck ran out a few weeks later: apprehended on 5 February 1934, he was sentenced to twenty-five to fifty years in the Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia for the machine-gun robbery of the Corn Exchange Bank.

Eastern State and the tunnel

Eastern State Penitentiary, a vast stone fortress in Philadelphia, was supposed to be escape-proof. Sutton spent more than a decade there, and he tried more than once to prove otherwise. In one attempt he fashioned a dummy head and hand in his own likeness, using real human hair, and placed them in his cot to fool the guards on their rounds.

His most ambitious attempt came on 3 April 1945, when Sutton was one of twelve convicts who crawled through a ninety-nine-foot tunnel dug over eleven months. They broke through to the surface in daylight and were spotted almost immediately by a passing police patrol; all twelve were quickly recaptured, Sutton the same day by Philadelphia police officer Mark Kehoe.

Because he was now a fourth-time offender, Sutton was sentenced to life imprisonment and transferred to the Philadelphia County Prison in Holmesburg. Less than two years later, on 10 February 1947, he escaped again: Sutton and other prisoners dressed as prison guards, carried two ladders across the yard after dark, and climbed the wall. When the prison searchlights found them, Sutton reportedly called out, “It’s all right!” — and nobody stopped him.

The FBI’s Most Wanted

The FBI created its Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list on 14 March 1950. Six days later, on 20 March, Sutton became the eleventh person ever listed on it — a bank robber who had escaped from three prisons and seemed to treat the law as a minor inconvenience. The wanted posters carried his aliases, including William Bowles, James Clayton, and Leo Holland, and described a man who could be anyone, because he had spent his career being anyone.

That talent for anonymity finally failed him on the Brooklyn subway in February 1952. Schuster recognised Sutton, followed him off the train, and brought the police to him. Sutton was arrested without a struggle, carrying identification in the name of Charles Gordon.

Schuster’s role in the capture made him briefly famous. He appeared on television to describe how he had helped catch Sutton. Less than a month later, on 9 March 1952, he was shot dead outside his home in Brooklyn. According to the Mafia informant Joe Valachi, the Gambino crime family boss Albert Anastasia had ordered the killing because he regarded Schuster as a “rat” and a “squealer.” No one was ever charged with Schuster’s murder, and Sutton maintained until his death that he had nothing to do with it. Schuster, who was twenty-four, is the human cost most often forgotten in the Sutton legend: a young man who did what the authorities asked citizens to do, and paid for it with his life.

Trial, Attica, and release

Sutton’s final trial was presided over by Judge Peter T. Farrell. In 1952, Sutton was convicted of the 1950 robbery of $63,942 from a branch of the Manufacturers Trust Company in Sunnyside, Queens, and sentenced to thirty to one hundred and twenty years in Attica State Prison.

In prison he wrote his first book, I, Willie Sutton (1953, with Quentin Reynolds), and remained in Attica for seventeen years.

In December 1969, Judge Farrell ruled that Sutton’s good behaviour in prison, together with his deteriorating health — he suffered from emphysema and needed an operation on the arteries in his legs — justified commuting his sentence to time served. Sutton wept as he was led from the courtroom, telling the judge, “Thank you, your Honor. God bless you.” He walked out of Attica State Prison on Christmas Eve, 1969. In 1970, a separate Brooklyn sentence was also commuted on similar grounds, and he was released on parole.

Freedom, at sixty-eight, suited Sutton better than anyone expected. He gave lectures on prison reform and consulted with banks on how to prevent robberies, advising the institutions he had once preyed upon. He also appeared in a television commercial for the New Britain Bank and Trust Company in Connecticut, promoting a credit card with picture identification. His line in the advertisement was: “They call it the ‘face card.’ Now when I say I’m Willie Sutton, people believe me.”

The line he said he never said

Sutton’s most famous quotation is: “Because that’s where the money is.” The story goes that a reporter, Mitch Ohnstad, asked him why he robbed banks, and Sutton gave that answer. The line entered medical teaching as “Sutton’s law” — the principle that a doctor should look first where the problem is most likely to be, rather than investigating every possibility. The earliest documented printed example of the line appeared in the Redlands Daily Facts on 15 March 1952.

There is only one problem with the story: Sutton said it never happened. In his second book, Where the Money Was (1976), co-authored with journalist Ed Linn, he denied originating the remark, writing that the credit belonged to “some enterprising reporter who apparently felt a need to fill out his copy.” He added that if anybody had asked him, he would probably have said it — “That’s what almost anybody would say… it couldn’t be more obvious” — but he could not even remember where he first read it: “It just seemed to appear one day, and then it was everywhere.”

What Sutton did say was more revealing than the line attributed to him. Asked why he robbed banks, he answered: “Because I enjoyed it. I loved it. I was more alive when I was inside a bank, robbing it, than at any other time in my life.” For Sutton, the money was, in his words, “the chips, that’s all.” The thrill was the point — a confession that strips away the Robin Hood gloss the public had painted over his career. He stole from banks, kept the money, and never claimed to give it to anyone.

The last years

Sutton spent his final years living with his sister in Spring Hill, Florida, keeping largely to himself. He died there on 2 November 1980, at the age of seventy-nine. His family arranged a quiet burial in the family plot in Brooklyn.

He left behind a peculiar legacy: a criminal who became a celebrity, a bank robber who advised banks, and a man whose most famous words were words he denied ever speaking. Eastern State Penitentiary, where Sutton spent eleven years and dug a tunnel to freedom, now lists him among its most notorious inmates.

The legend endures because Sutton was, by most accounts, genuinely charming, genuinely clever, and genuinely non-violent. But it should not obscure the record: his career was built on frightening ordinary people — bank tellers and customers held at gunpoint, even if the gun was unloaded — and on a young bystander, Arnold Schuster, whose life ended weeks after he helped catch him. Sutton never killed anyone. That is a fact, and it is to his credit. It is also the least the people he robbed were owed.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: William Francis Sutton Jr. was born on 30 June 1901 in Brooklyn and died on 2 November 1980 in Spring Hill, Florida, aged 79. He was sentenced to thirty years in Sing Sing in 1931 and escaped on 11 December 1932 using a smuggled gun, a hostage guard, and a ladder. He was sentenced to twenty-five to fifty years in Eastern State Penitentiary in 1934; on 3 April 1945 he was one of twelve inmates who escaped through a tunnel, and he was recaptured the same day by Officer Mark Kehoe. Sentenced to life as a fourth-time offender, he escaped from Holmesburg County Prison on 10 February 1947 dressed as a guard. He was listed as number 11 on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list on 20 March 1950. He was captured in Brooklyn in February 1952 after Arnold Schuster recognised him on the subway and followed him; Schuster was shot dead outside his home on 9 March 1952, and no one was ever charged. Sutton was convicted in 1952 of robbing $63,942 from the Manufacturers Trust Company in Sunnyside, Queens, and sentenced to thirty to one hundred and twenty years in Attica. Judge Peter T. Farrell commuted his sentence to time served in December 1969, and Sutton was released from Attica on Christmas Eve, 1969. He published I, Willie Sutton (1953) and Where the Money Was (1976), lectured on prison reform, consulted for banks, and appeared in a bank credit-card commercial. He never killed anyone during his criminal career.

Unverified or unproven: That Sutton ever said “Because that’s where the money is” — the line is apocryphal, and Sutton explicitly denied saying it in his autobiography; the earliest documented printed example dates to 15 March 1952 in the Redlands Daily Facts. That he never robbed a bank when a woman screamed or a baby cried — widely repeated, but anecdotal, with no official record behind it. That Albert Anastasia ordered Arnold Schuster’s murder — this comes from the account of Mafia informant Joe Valachi and has never been proven in court. The exact totals of his career — “about one hundred banks” and “an estimated two million dollars” — are estimates repeated across sources, not audited figures. Details of his early criminal career and family life rest largely on Sutton’s own memoirs and later biographies, and accounts differ on smaller points.

Sources

Leave a Comment