Harvey Bailey: The Dean of American Bank Robbers

Reading Time: 8 minutes ·

In the summer of 1933, Harvey Bailey was the most wanted bank robber in America. Federal agents had circulated his photograph across the country, newspapers called him the “Dean of American Bank Robbers,” and he was wanted in connection with a massacre at a Kansas City train station and the kidnapping of an Oklahoma oil millionaire. He was 45 years old, and by the reckoning of the men chasing him, he had robbed more banks than anyone else alive — nearly thirty of them, for more than a million dollars, over the course of a decade.

Bailey himself would later insist that he was a professional, not a killer. In his 1973 autobiography, Robbing Banks Was My Business, he presented bank robbery as a trade like any other: planned, rehearsed and carried out with as little violence as possible. The record partly supports him and partly does not. What is certain is that Bailey changed how American bank robbery was done, that his career ended in a single catastrophic summer, and that he then spent thirty years in prison before walking free at 76 and living out a quiet old age in Missouri.

A West Virginia farm boy who found Chicago

Harvey John Bailey was born in West Virginia on 23 August 1887. Little is reliably documented about his childhood. He served in the United States Army during the First World War, and afterwards drifted to Chicago, where Prohibition had made the city a boom town for anyone willing to work outside the law. He moved through bootlegging and hijacking stolen liquor before settling on bank robbery. His first bank robbery is generally dated to around 1921, at a bank in Northwestern, North Dakota. Over the 1920s he is credited with almost thirty robberies, taking more than a million dollars in total — an enormous sum when a skilled worker earned a few thousand dollars a year. Unlike the outlaws who followed him, Bailey avoided publicity. He did not want to be a folk hero.

The method: robbery as a business

What set Bailey apart, according to the historians and investigators who studied him, was his method. He treated each robbery as a project to be planned in detail. Before choosing a target, he reportedly studied the local economy and county tax records to work out when a bank would hold the most cash. He drove the escape routes in advance, timed them, and checked how far away the police station was and what cars the police had. He chose small-town banks in farming country, where the vault might hold a season’s worth of deposits and the nearest law enforcement was miles away.

The approach worked. His robberies were fast and, by the standards of the era, bloodless. Bailey maintained that he never fired a shot inside a bank, and there is no documented case of a bank employee or customer being killed during one of his robberies. That restraint was part of his reputation — and part of why other criminals sought him out.

His greatest success came on 17 September 1930, at the Lincoln National Bank in Lincoln, Nebraska. Six men, armed with pistols and Thompson submachine guns, took more than two million dollars — the largest bank robbery in American history up to that point. Bailey is credited with planning it. The loss was so large that the bank failed the following day, in an era before federal deposit insurance, leaving its depositors with nothing. It was the high-water mark of Bailey’s career, and it is worth remembering who paid for it: not the bank’s owners alone, but ordinary Nebraskans whose savings vanished overnight.

The crash, and a return to the trade

By the late 1920s, Bailey had reportedly retired from bank robbery and settled in Chicago, running a string of petrol stations and car washes. Then came the stock market crash of 1929. Bailey lost his money, and he went back to the only trade that had ever paid him well.

The return did not last long. In June 1932 he robbed a bank in Fort Scott, Kansas. On 12 July 1932 he was arrested in Fort Scott under the alias J. J. Brennan, and on 17 August 1932 he was received at the Kansas State Penitentiary at Lansing, sentenced to ten to fifty years for bank robbery. He was 44 years old, and it looked like the end of his career.

It was not. On 30 May 1933 — some accounts give 1 June — Bailey escaped from Lansing during a prison breakout in which the warden was seized and used as a human shield. He was free, a fugitive, and within weeks he would be at the centre of the two most sensational crimes of the summer.

The summer of 1933: a massacre and a kidnapping

On 17 June 1933, gunmen ambushed a group of law officers at Union Station in Kansas City, Missouri, as they were escorting the prisoner Frank Nash to Leavenworth. Four officers and Nash were killed: McAlester police chief Otto Reed, Kansas City police officers William J. Grooms and Frank E. Hermanson, and Special Agent Raymond J. Caffrey of the Bureau of Investigation. The killings became known as the Kansas City Massacre, and they shocked the country. Bailey, freshly escaped from Lansing, was a prime suspect. The Bureau’s identification order of 22 June 1933 listed him as wanted in connection with the murders, and hundreds of officers joined the manhunt.

Bailey was never convicted of any role in the massacre, and the question of who fired the shots has been argued ever since. The generally accepted account today names Verne Miller, “Pretty Boy” Floyd and Adam Richetti as the gunmen. Bailey always denied involvement. But in the summer of 1933, suspicion alone was enough to make him the most hunted man in America.

Meanwhile, a second crime was unfolding in Texas. On 22 July 1933, George “Machine Gun” Kelly and Albert Bates kidnapped the Oklahoma oil millionaire Charles F. Urschel from his home in Oklahoma City and held him at a farm near Paradise, Texas, owned by Robert “Boss” Shannon and his wife Ora. Urschel’s family paid a ransom of $200,000, and Urschel was released after nine days.

Bailey had fled to the Shannon farm after his escape from Lansing, using it as a hiding place. According to the historian Jay Nash, Bailey was staying in a separate part of the property, nursing a bullet wound in his leg sustained during his prison escape, and did not know that Urschel was being held there. When the ransom money was being divided, one of Kelly’s associates reportedly peeled off some bills and gave them to Bailey for his medical expenses. Those bills were marked, and they were found on Bailey when federal agents raided the farm at dawn on 12 August 1933. He was captured asleep on a cot in the farmyard, and taken to the Dallas County Jail.

Caught with the ransom money

Possession of the marked ransom money was devastating. Bailey, the Shannons and Bates were tried in Oklahoma City for their roles in the Urschel kidnapping, and on 7 October 1933 Bailey was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. The Kellys received the same sentence days later.

Bailey maintained until the end of his life that he had played no part in the kidnapping itself — that he had been a fugitive hiding on the farm, not a kidnapper — and some historians have found his account plausible. But the jury did not. The marked money in his pocket, and the company he was keeping, were enough.

He did not go quietly to his sentence. On 4 September 1933, while awaiting trial in the Dallas County Jail, a gun was slipped to him, he seized the jailer Nick Tresp as a hostage, and fled in the jailer’s car. He drove north into Oklahoma, but he was spotted stopping for petrol near Ardmore, and after a car chase through the town he lost control of his car, struck a kerb and was recaptured within hours. Tresp was unharmed. It was Bailey’s last escape.

Alcatraz and thirty years inside

Bailey began his life sentence at Leavenworth, but his reputation as an escape risk followed him. On 1 September 1934 he was transferred to Alcatraz, the new federal prison on an island in San Francisco Bay, where he was among its earliest inmates. He remained on “the Rock” until 1946, when he was returned to Leavenworth. In 1960 he was moved to the minimum-security Federal Correctional Institution at Seagoville, Texas, outside Dallas. He was released on 30 March 1964, aged 76, having spent more than thirty years behind bars.

His fellow prisoners from the Urschel case had fared worse. Albert Bates died at Alcatraz in 1948. George Kelly died in Leavenworth in 1954. Bailey outlived them all.

A quiet old age in Joplin

Freedom, when it finally came, was unremarkable — which seems to have suited Bailey. In 1966 he married Esther Farmer, the widow of Herbert Allen “Deafy” Farmer, and settled in Joplin, Missouri, where he found work as a woodworker in a furniture factory. In 1973 he published his autobiography, Robbing Banks Was My Business, written with the Texas historian J. Evetts Haley. In it, he denied any part in the Kansas City Massacre and in the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre of 1929, insisting that he and his associate Fred “Killer” Burke had been planning a bank robbery in Calumet City, Illinois, on the day of the Chicago killings.

Harvey Bailey died peacefully in Joplin on 1 March 1979, at the age of 91. He had spent roughly a third of his life in prison and the last fifteen years of it as a free man, a woodworker, and a husband. The “Dean of American Bank Robbers” ended his life not in a blaze of gunfire, as so many of his contemporaries did, but quietly, in a small Missouri town.

His legacy is a complicated one. He professionalised bank robbery, turning it from a smash-and-grab crime into a planned operation — a model that later generations of robbers copied. He also left behind real victims: the depositors of the Lincoln National Bank, the families of the officers killed at Union Station, and Charles Urschel, who spent nine days blindfolded in a farmhouse fearing for his life. Bailey’s own story, as he told it, was one of skill and restraint. The record tells a fuller story — of a talented criminal whose luck ran out in a single summer, and who paid for it with thirty years of his life.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Harvey John Bailey was born in West Virginia on 23 August 1887 and died in Joplin, Missouri, on 1 March 1979, aged 91. He served in the US Army in the First World War. He is credited with nearly thirty bank robberies in the 1920s, taking more than a million dollars. The 17 September 1930 robbery of the Lincoln National Bank in Lincoln, Nebraska, took more than two million dollars, a record at the time, and the bank failed the next day. Bailey was arrested at Fort Scott, Kansas, on 12 July 1932, received at Lansing on 17 August 1932 under a sentence of ten to fifty years, and escaped on 30 May 1933. The Kansas City Massacre took place on 17 June 1933, killing four officers and the prisoner Frank Nash. Charles F. Urschel was kidnapped on 22 July 1933 and released after a $200,000 ransom was paid. Federal agents arrested Bailey at the Shannon farm near Paradise, Texas, on 12 August 1933, and found marked ransom money on him. He escaped from the Dallas County Jail on 4 September 1933 and was recaptured the same day near Ardmore, Oklahoma. He was convicted of complicity in the Urschel kidnapping and sentenced to life imprisonment on 7 October 1933. He was transferred to Alcatraz on 1 September 1934, returned to Leavenworth in 1946, moved to Seagoville in 1960, and released on 30 March 1964. He married Esther Farmer in 1966, worked as a woodworker in Joplin, published his autobiography in 1973, and died in 1979.

Unverified or unproven: That Bailey personally planned the Lincoln National Bank robbery — he is widely credited with it, but the full planning record has never been established. That he never fired a shot inside a bank — this is Bailey’s own claim, repeated by sympathetic accounts, and no documented killing in a bank robbery is attributed to him, but it cannot be independently verified for every robbery credited to him. That he knew nothing of the Urschel kidnapping while staying at the Shannon farm — his own account, supported by Jay Nash, but the jury that convicted him did not accept it. That he took no part in the Kansas City Massacre — he was never convicted of it, and the generally accepted account names Miller, Floyd and Richetti, but the case was never fully resolved in court. The exact date of his escape from Lansing is given as both 30 May and 1 June 1933 in different sources. The commonly cited date of 9 September 1933 for his last bank robbery, at Kingfisher, Oklahoma, conflicts with his arrest on 12 August 1933 and should be treated as unreliable. That he and Fred Burke were planning a bank robbery in Calumet City at the time of the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre — Bailey’s own account, unverified.

Sources

Leave a Comment